As originally crafted, CCAA All-Canadians were selected on the basis of a formula which awards positions on the team according to its conference’s successes in the previous year’s tournament. The conference which finished first in the previous championships nominates three members to the All-Canadian team, the second, third and fourth place teams nominate two members to the team, while the remaining conferences each nominate one member for a total of 10 team members. In subsequent years, each conference has essentially voted on its two representatives to the All-Canadian team.
| CCAA 1st | 2nd | |
| 74-75 | ||
| 75-76 | Varouj Gurunlian – Dawson Wayne Smith – Dawson Herman Sheppard – George Brown Gary McKeigan – George Brown Frank Willis – Lethbridge (all-tourney selections were all-Canadian selections according to Eddie Pomykala) | |
| 76-77 | Eddie Pomykala – Dawson Trevor Bennett – Dawson Murray Redekop – Briercrest Bible Jim Ralph – Lethbridge Leonard Noel – Seneca *Frank Peters – Briercrest Bible (all-tourney selections were all-Canadian selections according to Eddie Pomykala) | |
| 77-78 | Harley Lawrence – Dawson Ambrose Campana – Sheridan Kevin Dogan – Vanier Gerald Vermeulen – N.S. Agricultural Murray Redekop – Briercrest Bible | Bob Horvath – Fanshawe Henry Koscielski – St. Clair Rob Wilson – Mt. Royal Todd Rutherford – Grant McEwen Eddie Muha – Dawson |
| 78-79 | Kim O’Leary – Vancouver C.C. Don Janzen – Mt. Royal Bob Horvath – Fanshawe Francois Dion – Maisonneuve Brian Eves – Mohawk | Glenn Lipomanis – John Abbott Lawrence Coombs – Centennial Tim Herr – Mount Royal Brian Sexton – N.S. Agricultural Joe Branstein – George Brown |
| 79-80 | ||
| 80-81 | ||
| 81-82 | David Joseph – SAIT David Klassen – Okanagan Mike Berger – Vancouver CC Wes Thiessen – Briercrest Bible Inst. Ray Priam – Red River CC Perry Kazulak – Mohawk Serge Trivanovich – Centennial Craig Norman – Dawson Jimmy Maniati – Vanier John Lohr – Nova Scotia Agricultural | |
| 82-83 | Terry Finnigan – Red Deer Joe Boetticher – Medicine Hat Wayne Yearwood – Dawson Robert Defort – Maisonneuve Kerry Lichty – Mohawk Larry Cassanova – Sheridan Tim McGarrigle – Cape Breton Roy Houssin – Assiniboine CC Curtis Frisque – Briercrest Bible Cord Clemens – Vancouver CC | |
| 83-84 | Derrick Dell – SAIT Curtis French – Lethbridge CC Doug McKinlay – Humber Larry Fleury – Assiniboine Brian Larson – Sask. Technical Institute Tim McGarrigle – Cape Breton Robert Dufour – Maisonneuve Chris Francis – Dawson Mark Marter – Capilano Kevin Hanson – Vancouver CC | |
| 84-85 | Ryan Heggie – Lethbridge CC Marty Lutz – Vancouver CC Chad Nickolson – Medicine Hat Curt Lorge – Saskatchewan Technical Institute Kevin St. Kitts – Sheridan Pierre Tibblin – Vanier Emilio Rocca – Fanshawe Tim Kendrick – N.S. Teachers Garfield Glasgow – Champlain Terry Lamoureux – Red River CC | |
| 85-86 | Trevor Hamilton – SAIT Sergio Bolzon – Mohawk Marcel Langlois – Algonquin Kevin Newcombe – N.S. Teachers Kelly Rambeau – N.S. Teachers Kevin Korol – Vancouver CC Dwight Walton – Dawson College Grant Sylvester – Canadian Bible Raymond Branch – Assiniboine | |
| 86-87 | Ted Leslie – SAIT Trevor Hamilton – SAIT David Smith – Seneca George McNeil – Humber Astley Smith – Dawson Leon Pierre – John Abbott Kevin Korol – Vancouver CC Shawn Coupland – Canadian Bible Keith Donovan – King’s | |
| 87-88 | Rae Fehr – SAIT Chris Croft – Medicine Hat Paul Chaffee – Trinity Western Jeff Strother – Cariboo Grant Sylvester – Canadian Bible George McNeil – Humber Floyd Cobran – Seneca Michael Smith – Dawson Leon Pierre – John Abbott David Brown – U. of King’s College | |
| 88-89 | Brian Haynes – SAIT John Cislo – Medicine Hat Charles Raymond – Vancouver CC Glen Coté – Douglas Robert Bonnick – George Brown Earl Moncrieffe – Humber Robert Ferguson – Vanier Danny Eveleigh – Champlain-St. Lambert Donnie MacLean – U. of King’s College Craig McDougall – SIAST-Palliser | |
| 89-90 | Brice Crowle – Mount Royal Chris Neureuter – Grant McEwen Paul Chaffee – Trinity Western Doug Devries – Trinity Western Cyril Veniot – Nova Scotia Teachers Donnie MacLean – Univ. of King’s College Emerson Thomas – Vanier Benoit Deschamps – Dawson Patrick Rhodd – Humber Perry Martens – Briercrest Bible | |
| 90-91 | Darren Ross – Grant McEwen Cory Klassen – Malaspina Benoit Deschamps – Dawson André Costa – Lethbridge CC Peter Walcott – Vanier Patrick Rhodd – Humber Mark Forward – Mt. St. Vincent Perry Martens – Briercrest Bible Andrew Longley – Nova Scotia Teachers Justin Jones – Sheridan | |
| 91-92 | Ray Raymond – Mount Royal Cyril Veinot – Nova Scotia Teachers Eric Frantz – Montmorency Christopher Cain – Champlain Peter Rubin – Vancouver CC Brett Nohr – Malaspina Rod Adrian – Briercrest Bible Prentice Lenz – Briercrest Bible Fitzroy Lightbody – Humber Kevin Taylor – George Brown | |
| 92-93 | Darren Ross – Grant McEwen Vern Knopp – Douglas Rod Charlton – Okanagan Jeremy Adrian – Briercrest Bible Brad Peak – Algonquin Patrick Rhodd – Humber Maxime Bouchard – Montmorency Steven Thomas – Vanier Tony Ross – Mt. St. Vincent Dave Brown – Univ. of King’s College | |
| 93-94 | Vern Knopp – Douglas Marty Penninga – Trinity Western Chris Brinnen – Grande Prairie RC Stefan DaSilva – Briercrest Bible Mike Tatlock – Prairie Bible Brad Peak – Algonquin George Frempong – Sheridan Bobby Miller – Montmorency Cory Taylor – Nova Scotia Teachers Chad Edison – Nova Scotia Agricultural | |
| 94-95 | Louis Johnson – Langara Chris McClean – Malaspina Marty Penninga – Trinity Western Darren Semeniuk – Grant MacEwan Brady Layton – Mount Royal Augusto Duquesne – Durham Steve McGregor – Humber Hennssy Auriantal – Dawson Bobby Miller – Montmorency Kevin Hayden – Nova Scotia Teachers | |
| 95-96 | Marc-Olivier Bessette – Champlain Warren Daniel – Vanier Navi Sekhon – Langara Nino Sose – Cariboo Mark Clarke – Mt. St. Vincent Augusto Duquesne – Durham George Frempong – Sheridan Donovan Brown – Sheridan Shay Yellowhorn – SAIT Marc Croteau – Augustana | |
| 96-97 | Rowan Beckford – Humber Keith Gough – Algonquin Rodwin Auriantal – Dawson Marc-Andre Demers – Montmorency Marc-Leone Volcy – Montmorency Louis Johnson – Langara Patrick Lowen – Malaspina Troy Gedlaman – Mount Royal Jonathon Williams – King’s (Alta). Matt Clarke – Mt. St. Vincent | |
| 97-98 | Kirk Reid – Dawson Philippe Langlois – Montmorency Tim Mathieson – Loyalist Shane Bascoe – Sheridan Jimmy Parsons – St. Clair Charlton Weaselhead – Lethbridge Peter Buwalda – King’s College (Alberta) Aaron Mitchell – Langara Patrick Lowen – Malaspina Seth Kingsbury – N.S.A.C. | |
| 98-99 | Bill Crowdis – Durham Randy Nohr – Langara Patrick Lowen – Malaspina Chad Yarwood – Fraser Valley Philippe Langlois – Montmorency Shane Bascoe – Sheridan Troy Arnett – Red Deer Calvin Palmer – Mount Royal Alvin Bell – New Brunswick-Saint John Charles Fortier – Montmorency | |
| 99-00 | Aaron Mitchell – Langara James Maksymiw – Langara Wayne Jones – Fraser Valley Shawn Kennedy – SAIT Mark Harvey – King’s University College (Alta) Shane Bascoe – Sheridan Abraham Osman – Algonquin Eugene Ambrose – Champlain Charles Fortier – Montmorency Mike Bonnar – St. Thomas | |
| 00-01 | Jeremy Luypen – Okanagan Ryan Porter – Cariboo Dana Larsen – Northern British Columbia Robbie Valpreda – Grant MacEwan Dion Horsford – George Brown Cornell Brown – Humber Dominique Soucy – Sainte-Foy Bernard Cote – Champlain Mike Bonnar – St. Thomas Ian MacRae – Mount Saint Vincent | |
| 01-02 | Ryan Porter – Cariboo Dean Whalen – U of Northern British Columbia Jason Damery – NAIT Edward Richardson III – SAIT Hugh Bent – Sheridan Fitzroy Woolery – Humber Jean-Philippe Morin – Montmorency Mario Joseph – Dawson Kevin Hobbs – University of King’s College Allan Williams – Mount Saint Vincent | |
| 02-03 |
Peter Wauthy – Fraser Valley Taylor Cherris-Wilding – Douglas Loren Balon – NAIT Jeremy Odland – Prairie Bible Jonathan Bell – Algonquin Dave Love – Georgian Damian Buckley – Vanier Jean Philippe Morin – Montmorency David Robson – St. Thomas Rob Turnbull – Mount Saint Vincent | |
| 03-04 | Skye Buck – Cariboo Chris Spoor – Camosun Loren Balon – NAIT Edward Richardson III – SAIT Shane Dennie – Humber Ryan Bennison – Algonquin Damian Buckley – Vanier Pierre Marie Cespedes – Champlain-St-Lambert Barry Bryan – Mount Saint Vincent David Robson – St. Thomas | |
| 04-05 | Sean Garvey – Cariboo Jason Hubbs – Malaspina Michael Page – Lakeland Robbie Valpreda – Grant MacEwan Ndale Philbert – George Brown Louis Moore – Sheridan Christopher Warner – Dawson Maurice Joseph – Champlain-Saint Lambert Shawn Clarke – Mount Saint Vincent Aaron Carpenter – University of King’s College | |
| 05-06 | Jamie Vaughan – Fraser Valley Anthony Lao – Langara William Archambault – Champlain Josh Whyte – Mount Royal B.J. Charles – Algonquin Tim Adams – University of King’s College Jean Louis Ouattara – Sault Etienne Labrecque – Montmorency Mike Page – Lakeland Brendon Arnold – Mount Saint Vincent | |
| 06-07 |
Andrew Sturgeon – Douglas Jean-Paul Kamand – Capilano Clarence Smith – Lakeland Jeff Price – Mount Royal Ahmed Eman – Algonquin Pat Sewell – Fanshawe Marc-David Vil – Montmorency Jérôme Turcotte – Sainte-Foy Damian Gay – Mount Saint Vincent Doyle Anthony – Mount Allison | |
| 07-08 | Neil O’Sullivan – Sir Sanford Fleming-Peterborough Anthony Moore – John Abbott Brendon Arnold – Mount Saint Vincent Jeff Spoor – Camosun Anthony Batchelor – Durham Emmanuel Chiek – Mount Royal Billy McNutt – Douglas Kyle Desmarais – Dawson Adam Jones – Grande Prairie Damian Gay – Mount Saint Vincent | |
| 08-09 | Clint Wickham – Langara Inderbir Gill – Northern British Columbia Ossie Hinds – Lakeland Denver Corbiere – Lethbridge Charly Spurr – Algonquin Brady Bolan – Cambrian Ryan Rozsnaki – Dawson Vincent Lanctot-Fortier – Montmorency Jason Carlson – Mount Saint Vincent Clint Bateman – Atlantic Baptist | |
| 09-10 |
Inderbir Gill – Northern British Columbia Andrew Kaban – Vancouver Island University Brett Kobe – Mount Royal University Gregg Frankson – MacEwan University Jovain Wilson – Fleming College David Korenic – St. Clair College Yann Charles – Collège Champlain St. Lambert Robinson Odoch Opong – Cégep de Sainte-Foy Adam Jewkes – Mount Saint Vincent University Josh Graham – Mount Allison University | |
| 10-11 |
Inderbir
Gill – University of Northern BC Jacob Thom – Vancouver Island Dominyck Coward – Lethbridge College Bol Kong – Northern Alberta Institute of Technology Eric Smith – Durham Njuguna Waiganjo – Algonquin Guillaume Payen-Boucard – Collège Ahuntsic Boris Hadzimuratovic – Sainte Foy Donathan Moss – Holland J.D. Howlett – University of King’s College | |
| 11-12 | Jovain Wilson – Algoma Aminu Bello – Mohawk Jacob Thom – Vancouver Island Mamadou Médoune Gueye – Sainte-Foy Gurjote Jhaj – Langara Leo Morris – Holland Eamon Morrissy – University of King’s College Youssef Ouahrig – Champlain Saint-Lambert Ethan Sir – Concordia JD Howlett – University of King’s College Zach Waldher – Keyano | |
| 12-13 | Felix Adjei – Seneca François Bourque – Montmorency Manny Campbell – Mohawk Gradyn Childerhose – Briercrest College & Seminary Ben Chisholm – Mount Allison Brody Greig – Langara Brandon Jones – Vancouver Island Mamadou Médoune Gueye – Sainte-Foy Nathan Mazurkiewicz – St. Thomas Milos Prijovic – Concordia U College of Alberta | |
| 13-14 | Osman Barrie – Crandall Yonas Berhe – NAIT Chase Bowden – Holland Dominyck Coward – Lethbridge Matt Fennell – Mohawk Brody Greig – Langara Vadim Halimov – George Brown Brandon Jones – Vancouver Island Alexandre Leclerc – Sainte-Foy Tevonn Walker – Vanier | |
| 14-15 | Matthew Fennell – Mohawk Justin King – Vancouver Island Jitinder Lohcham – Langara Donathan Moss – NAIT Guilherme Carabagtiale Fuck – Medicine Hat Tequilan Zwarych – Georgian Kasheem Thomas – Champlain-St. Lambert Jordan Aquino-Serjue – Dawson D.J. Wright – Holland William Barber – St. Thomas | |
| 15-16 | Josh Ross – Vancouver Island Theo VandenEkart – Quest Kyler Shula – Ambrose Wayne Tucker Jr. – Olds Rayvon Higdon – Redeemer Jaz Bains – St. Lawrence-Kingston Keevon Small – John Abbott Kasheem Thomas – Champlain-St. Lawrence Thomarcus Nix – Crandall Trevone Grant – Holland | |
| 16-17 | Usama Zaid – Vancouver Island Ravi Basra – Langara Ian Tevis – Red Deer Jackson Jacob – NAIT Rayvon Higdon – Redeemer Ajahmo Clarke – George Brown Alix Lochard – Montmorency Kevin Civil – Montmorency Thomarcus Nix – Crandall Trenity Burdine – Holland | |
| 17-18 | Usama Zaid – Vancouver Island Kenny Johnson – Grande Prairie Rayvon Higdon – Redeemer Lochard – Montmorency LeGallais – Mount Allison Ravi Basra – Langara Murphy Beya – SAIT Khalil Miller – Seneca Guillaume Pepin – Jean-de-Brebeuf Brandon Fields – Crandall | |
| 18-19 | Jace Colley – Holland Harry Fayle – Vancouver Island Denver Sparks-Guest – Capilano Ryan McLaren – Concordia University John Smith – SAIT Van Hutchinson Jr – Niagara Brandon Halliburton – Durham Eli Karojo – Montmorency Karim Mane – Vanier Roosevelt Whyley – Holland | |
| 19-20 | Nick Campbell – Sheridan Courtney Anderson – Douglas Tyus Barfoot – Vancouver Island Brock Dewsbery – Lethbridge Sean-Michael Clancey – NAIT Dakoda Lewis – Seneca Sebastien Lamaute – Jean-de-Brebeuf Karim Mane – Vanier Jordan Holness – Holland Geoffrey Lavoie – St. Thomas | |
| 20-21 | None selected (cancelled, covid-19 pandemic) | |
| 21-22 | Akoi Yuot – Vancouver Island Takeshi Croke – Camosun Sean Michael-Clancey – Keyano Tyronn King – Red Deer Nathan Bowie – Alberta-Augustana Zerious Loney – Algonquin DeQuon Cascart – Humber David Gomez Jr – St. Clair Renoldo Robinson – Dawson Karl-Tommy Laforest – Montmorency Yannice Nlend – Thetford Jordan Holness – Holland Sam Pierson – Mount Allison | |
| 22-23 | Tori Odom – Vancouver Island Tyrone Asenoguan – Capilano Sean-Michael Clancey – Keyano Marcus Masters – SAIT Brock Dewsbery – St. Mary’s Ladera Ujullu-Obang – Conestoga Adam Hosseini – Durham Shakael Pryce – St. Clair Édouard Benoit – Jean-de-Brébeuf Omar Migues-Hibeljic – Jean-de-Brébeuf Louis Daoust – Vanier Geoff Lavoie – St. Thomas Will Spaulding – Mount St. Vincent | |