| PLAYER OF THE YEAR | COACH OF THE YEAR | |
| 59-60 | NB-PEI: Laird McLennan – New Brunswick | |
| 60-61 | ||
| 61-62 | ||
| 62-63 | ||
| 63-64 | ||
| 64-65 | ||
| 65-66 | ||
| 66-67 | Don Nelson – New Brunswick | |
| 67-68 | ||
| 68-69 | ||
| 69-70 | ||
| 70-71 | ||
| 71-72 | ||
| 72-73 | ||
| 73-74 | ||
| 74-75 | Gary Heald – UPEI | |
| 75-76 | ||
| 76-77 | Ed Shannon – Acadia | Dick Hunt – Acadia |
| 77-78 | Dick Hunt – Acadia | |
| 78-79 | Kevin Wood – Saint Mary’s | Kevin Feighrey – U.P.E.I. |
| 79-80 | Mike Hazard – Acadia | Gary Heald – Saint Mary’s |
| 80-81 | Ted Upshaw – Acadia | Ian MacMillan – Acadia |
| 81-82 | John Hatch – St. FX | Gary Heald – Saint Mary’s |
| 82-83 | John Hatch – St. FX | Steve Konchalski – St. FX |
| 83-84 | John Hatch – St. FX | Gary Heald – Saint Mary’s |
| 84-85 | Chris Sumner – Acadia | George Morrison – U.P.E.I. |
| 85-86 | Kyle Gayle – ST. FX | Dave Nutbrown – Acadia |
| 86-87 | Peter Morris – Acadia | Dave Nutbrown – Acadia |
| 87-88 | Peter Morris – Acadia | Dave Nutbrown – Acadia |
| 88-89 | Peter Gordon – U.P.E.I. | Dave Nutbrown – Acadia |
| 89-90 | Peter Gordon – U.P.E.I. | Ross Quackenbush – Saint Mary’s |
| 90-91 | Peter Gordon – U.P.E.I. | Steve Konchalski – St. FX |
| 91-92 | Brian Thompson – Saint Mary’s | Tim McGarrigle – Cape Breton |
| 92-93 | William Njoku – Saint Mary’s | Ross Quackenbush – Saint Mary’s |
| 93-94 | William Njoku – Saint Mary’s | Tim McGarrigle – Cape Breton |
| 94-95 | Curtis Robinson – U.P.E.I. | Glenn Taylor – Memorial |
| 95-96 | Curtis Robinson – U.P.E.I. | George Morrison – U.P.E.I. |
| 96-97 | Peter Benoite – Memorial | Glenn Taylor – Memorial |
| 97-98 | Jan Trojanowski – Acadia | Dave Nutbrown – Acadia |
| 98-99 | Jan Trojanowski – Acadia | Dave Nutbrown – Acadia |
| 99-00 | Fred Perry – St. FX | Steve Konchalski – St. FX |
| 00-01 | Fred Perry – St. FX | Steve Konchalski – St. FX |
| 01-02 | Mike Kierstead – U.N.B. | Thom Gillespie – New Brunswick |
| 02-03 | Gabe Goree – Saint Mary’s | Steve Konchalski – St. FX |
| 03-04 | Gabe Goree – Saint Mary’s | Thom Gillespie – New Brunswick |
| 04-05 | Sherone Edwards – U.P.E.I. | Jim Charters – Cape Breton |
| 05-06 | Jerome Goodman – Saint Mary’s | Steve Konchalski – St. FX |
| 06-07 | Paulo Santana – Acadia | Les Barry – Acadia (revoked) |
| 07-08 | Leonel Saintil – Acadia | Jim Charters – Cape Breton |
| 08-09 | Christian Upshaw – St. Francis Xavier | Jim Charters – Cape Breton |
| 09-10 | Christian Upshaw – St. Francis Xavier | Jim Charters – Cape Breton |
| 10-11 | Joey Haywood – Saint Mary’s | John Campbell – Dalhousie |
| 11-12 | Jimmy Dorsey – Cape Breton | Tim Kendrick – U.P.E.I. |
| 12-13 | Jimmy Dorsey – Cape Breton | Matt Skinn – Cape Breton |
| 13-14 | Owen Klassen – Acadia | Stephen Baur – Acadia |
| 14-15 | Javon Masters – New Brunswick | Brent Baker – New Brunswick |
| 15-16 | Javon Masters – New Brunswick | Rick Plato – Dalhousie |
| 16-17 | Kevin Bercy – St. Francis Xavier | Rick Plato – Dalhousie |
| 17-18 | Javon Masters – New Brunswick | Brent Baker – New Brunswick |
| 18-19 | Kemar Alleyne – Saint Mary’s | Jonah Taussig – Saint Mary’s |
| 19-20 | Keevan Veinot – Dalhousie | Rick Plato – Dalhousie |
| 20-21 | None selected (season cancelled) | None selected (season cancelled) |
| 21-22 | Osman Omar – Cape Breton | Rick Plato – Dalhousie |
| 22-23 | Elijah Miller – U.P.E.I | Tyrell Vernon – St. FX |
| 23-24 | Malcolm Christie – Dalhousie | Jonah Taussig – Saint Mary’s |
| 24-25 | D.J. Jackson – St. FX | Darrell Glenn – UPEI |
| 25-26 | D.J. Jackson – St. FX | Tyrell Vernon – St. FX |
| ROOKIE OF THE YEAR | DEFENSIVE MVP | |
| 63-64 | ||
| 64-65 | ||
| 65-66 | ||
| 66-67 | ||
| 67-68 | ||
| 68-69 | ||
| 69-70 | ||
| 70-71 | ||
| 71-72 | ||
| 72-73 | ||
| 73-74 | ||
| 74-75 | ||
| 75-76 | ||
| 76-77 | ||
| 77-78 | Ted Upshaw – Acadia | |
| 78-79 | Larry McGee – U.P.E.I. | |
| 79-80 | Scott Devine – UNB | |
| 80-81 | Lee Davis – Saint Mary’s | |
| 81-82 | Larry Hampton – Acadia | |
| 82-83 | Chris Sumner – Acadia | |
| 83-84 | Al Phillips – St. FX | |
| 84-85 | Dag Rutherford – UNB (after Ron Lardge – Saint Mary’s forfeited the award because he was ineligible) | |
| 85-86 | Manfred Hoyer – UNB | |
| 86-87 | Peter Gordon – PEI | |
| 87-88 | Peter Gordon – U.P.E.I. | |
| 88-89 | Wayne Taylor – Acadia | |
| 89-90 | Marion Mathis – St. FX | |
| 90-91 | Richard Bella – St. FX | |
| 91-92 | John Ryan – Cape Breton | |
| 92-93 | Curtis Robinson – U.P.E.I. | |
| 93-94 | Shawn Plancke – Dalhousie | |
| 94-95 | Stanleigh Mitchell – U.N.B. | |
| 95-96 | Micah Bourdeau – Saint Mary’s | |
| 96-97 | Jordan McCormack – Saint Mary’s/ Jermaine Bruce – Memorial | |
| 97-98 | Jonah Taussig – Saint Mary’s | |
| 98-99 | Jeff Cotter – New Brunswick | |
| 99-00 | Mike Kierstead – New Brunswick | |
| 00-01 | Jeff Saxby – Memorial | |
| 01-02 | Oreine Davis – Dalhousie | |
| 02-03 | Nicholas Landrigan – Acadia | |
| 03-04 | Sherone Edwards – UPEI | |
| 04-05 | Garry Gallimore – St. FX | Garry Gallimore – St. Francis Xavier |
| 05-06 | Mark McLaughlin – Saint Mary’s | Garry Gallimore – St. Francis Xavier |
| 06-07 | Christian Upshaw – St. FX | Garry Gallimore – St. Francis Xavier |
| 07-08 | Islam Luis de Toledo – St. FX | Achuil Lual – Acadia |
| 08-09 | Casey Fox – Acadia | Phillip Nkrumah – Cape Breton |
| 09-10 | Owen Klassen – Acadia | Phillip Nkrumah – Cape Breton |
| 10-11 | William McFee – New Brunswick | Phillip Nkrumah – Cape Breton |
| 11-12 | Brian Rouse – Saint Mary’s | Owen Klassen – Acadia |
| 12-13 | Deontay Smith – UPEI | Owen Klassen – Acadia |
| 13-14 | Javon Masters – New Brunswick | Owen Klassen – Acadia |
| 14-15 | Ben Miller – Acadia | Ritchie Kanza Mata – Dalhousie |
| 15-16 | Jordan Aquino-Serjue – Dalhousie | Meshack Lufile – Cape Breton |
| 16-17 | Jamaal Potopsingh – New Brunswick | Ritchie Kanza Mata – Dalhousie |
| 17-18 | Nikita Kasongo – Saint Mary’s | Erik Nissen – Acadia |
| 18-19 | Emanuel Ring – Memorial | Paul Watson – Cape Breton |
| 19-20 | Avan Nava – St. FX | Xavier Ochu – Dalhousie |
| 20-21 | None selected (season cancelled) | None selected (season cancelled) |
| 21-22 | Norm Burry – New Brunswick | Samuel Maillet – Dalhousie |
| 22-23 | Marcus Barnes – New Brunswick | David Muenkat – St. FX |
| 23-24 | Koat Thomas – St. Francis Xavier | Javordo Mitchell – New Brunswick |
| 24-25 | Ryan Regault – Acadia | Jeff Ngandu – St. FX |
| 25-26 | Phoenyx Wyse – St. FX | Brandon Laryea – New Burnswick |