| ALL-CANADIAN 1ST-TEAM | 2ND-TEAM | |
| 11-12 | None selected | None selected |
| 12-13 | Joey Haywood – Halifax Greg Surmacz – Windsor Sheray Thomas – Montreal-Saint John Antwi Atuahene – London Kevin Loiselle – Windsor | Quincy Okolie – Halifax Papa Oppong – Oshawa Kamar Burke – Moncton Doug McKinney – Summerside Kevin Francis – Saint John |
| 13-14 | Evaldas Zabas – Brampton A’s Alex Johnson – Mississauga Power Garrett Williamson – London Lightning Kevin Loiselle – Windsor Express Oluyiuma Famutimi – Halifax Rainmen | None selected |
| 14-15 | Tyrone Watson – Halifax Joey Haywood – Halifax Gary Gibson – Windsor Alex Johnson – Mississauga/Saint John Ashton Smith – Brampton | None selected |
| 15-16 | Warren Ward – London Lightning Joel Friesen – Halifax Hurricanes Clinton Springer-Williams – Niagara River Lions Terry Thomas – Island Storm Shaquille Keith – Windsor Express | None selected |
| 16-17 | Jason Calliste – Kitchener-Waterloo Titans Kyle Johnson – London Lightning Joel Friesen – London Lightning Terry Thomas – Island Storm Warren Ward – Windsor Express | Junior Cadougan – London Lightning Olumuyiwa Famutimi – Saint John Riptide Alex Johnson – Orangeville A’s Shaquille Keith – Cape Breton Highlanders/Windsor Express Tyrone Watson – Halifax Hurricanes 3rd Richard Amardi – Niagara River Lions Joey Haywood – Halifax Hurricanes Stefan Nastić – Orangeville A’s Jameson Tipping – Orangeville A’s Garrett Williamson – London Lightning |
| 17-18 | Carl English – St. John’s Edge Garrett Williamson – London Lightning Terry Thomas – Moncton Magic Guillaume Payen-Boucard – Niagara River Lions Tramar Sutherland – Kitchener-Waterloo Titans | Alex Johnson – St. John’s Edge Chris Johnson – Island Storm Kyle Johnson – London Lightning Shaquille Keith – Windsor Express Tyrone Watson – Halifax Hurricanes 3rd Sefton Barrett – London Lightning/Windsor Express Grandy Glaze – St. John’s Edge Joel Friesen-Latty – London Lightning Tyler Scott – Island Storm Marvell Waithe – Niagara River Lions/Moncton Magic |
| 18-19 | Guillaume Boucard – Island Storm Junior Cadougan – St. John’s Edge Alex Campbell – Island Storm Garrett Williamson – London Lightning Jamal Reynolds – Cape Breton Highlanders | Ashton Smith – Kitchener-Waterloo Titans Chris Johnson – Cape Breton Highlanders Chadrack Lufile – Halifax Hurricanes Terry Thomas – Halifax Hurricanes Denzell Taylor – Moncton Magic 3rd Gentrey Thomas – Moncton Magic Jason Calliste – Moncton Magic Tramar Sutherland – Kitchener-Waterloo Titans Alex Johnson – London Lightning Aaron Redpath – Cape Breton Highlands |
| 19-20 | Alex Campbell – Island Storm Kemy Osse – Windsor Junior Cadougan – St. John’s Jason Calliste – Moncton Tyrone Watson – St. John’s | Denzell Taylor – Moncton Nigel Tyghter – Kitchener-Waterloo Garrett Williamson – London Chris Johnson – Halifax Jarryn Skeete – Sudbury |
| 20-21 | Season cancelled (covid-19 pandemic) | Season cancelled (covid-19 pandemic) |
| 21-22 | Terry Thomas – London Lightning Jason Calliste – Sudbury Five Jermaine Haley – London Lightning Elijah Ifejeh – Windsor Express Marcus Anderson – Windsor Express | None selected |
| 22-23 | Mike Nuga – London Lightning Marcus Ottey – London Lightning Terry Thomas – London Lightning Duane Notice – Sudbury Five Jason Calliste – Windsor Express | |
| ALL-LEAGUE 1ST-TEAM | 2ND-TEAM & 3RD (if selected) | |
| 11-12 | Anthony Anderson – Saint John Mill Rats Gabe Freeman – London Lightning Ralphy Holmes – Quebec Kebs Mike Williams – Summerside Storm Lawrence Wright – Halifax Rainmen | Tim Ellis – London Lightning Omari Johnson – Oshawa Power Trayvon Lathan – Moncton Miracles Tyrone Levett – London Lightning / Halifax Rainmen Brandon Robinson – Oshawa Power |
| 12-13 | Darren Duncan – Halifax-Windsor Devin Sweetney – Moncton Brandon Robinson – Halifax-Summerside Elvin Mims – London Isaac Butts – Moncton | Anthony Anderson – Saint John Jerice Crouch – Saint John Tim Ellis – London Quinnel Brown – Halifax Marvin Phillips – London 3rd Nick Okorie – Oshawa Al Stewart – Summerside Chris Commons – Windsor Joey Haywood – Halifax Antonio Ballard – Summerside |
| 13-14 | Anthony Anderson – Saint John Stefan Bonneau – Windsor Cedric Moodie – Brampton Garrrett Williamson – London Antonio Ballard – The Island | Ryan Anderson – Ottawa Morgan Lewis – Mississauga Chris Commons – Windsor Tim Parham – Halifax Cavell Johnson – Brampton 3rd Darren Duncan – Windsor Nick Okorie – Mississauga / The Island Johnny Mayhane – Moncton Jermaine Johnson – Ottawa/London Jason Williams – Halifax HM Marvin Phillips – London Lightning Travyon Lathan – Moncton Miracles Justin Tubbs – Ottawa SkyHawks Doug Herring Jr. – Saint John Mill Rats Stanley Robinson – Moncton Miracles Evaldas Zabas – Brampton A’s JuJuan Cooley – Halifax Rainmen Adrian Moss – Island Storm Quinnel Brown – Windsor Express William “Bo” Harris – Mississauga Power Tony Bennett – London Lightning Tyrone Levett – Saint John Mill Rats Elvin Mims – London Lightning |
| 14-15 | Quinnel Brown – Windsor Kevin Young – Halifax Marvin Phillips – London Brandon Robinson – The Island Anthony Anderson – Saint John | Tyshwan Edmondson – Brampton Tyrone Watson – Halifax Omar Strong – Mississauga Kenny Jones – Saint John DeAndre Thomas – Windsor 3rd Nick Okorie – The Island Tony Bennett – Windsor Chris Commons – Windsor Cavell Johnson – Brampton Trayvon Lathan – Moncton |
| 15-16 | Logan Stutz – Niagara River Lions Stephen Maxwell – London Lightning Gabe Freeman – Saint John Mill Rats Brandon Robinson – Windsor Express Justin Johnson – Halifax Hurricanes | Kyle Hunt – Halifax Hurricanes Chris Commons – Windsor Express James Justice – Moncton Miracles Mike Glover – Halifax Hurricanes Anthony Anderson – Saint John Mill Rats 3rd Akeem Wright – London Lightning Justin Moss – Orangeville A’s Akeem Scott – London Lightning Doug Herring Jr – Saint John Mill Rats Dexter Strickland – Moncton Miracles |
| 16-17 | Royce White – London Lightning Gabe Freeman – Saint John Riptide Rahlir Hollis-Jefferson – Orangeville A’s Terry Thomas – Island Storm Billy White – Halifax Hurricanes | Anthony Anderson – Saint John Riptide Clifford Clinkscales – Halifax Hurricanes Ryan Anderson – London Lightning Jahii Carson – The Island Storm Chad Frazier – Cape Breton Highlanders 3rd Maurice Jones – Windsor Express Flenard Whitfield – Kitchener-Waterloo Titans Malik Story – Moncton Miracles Garrett Williamson – London Lightning CJ Washington – Halifax Hurricanes |
| 17-18 | Carl English – St. John’s Edge Terry Thomas – Moncton Magic Billy White – Halifax Hurricanes Royce White – London Lightning Garrett Williamson – London Lightning | Charles Hinkle – St. John’s Edge Antoine Mason – Halifax Hurricanes Bruce Massey – Cape Breton Highlanders Du’Vaughn Maxwell – Island Storm Franklin Session – Island Storm 3rd Derek Hall – Kitchener-Waterloo Titans Doug Herring Jr. – London Lightning Maurice Jones – Windsor Express Malcolm Miller – Saint John Riptide Jaylon Tate – Niagara River Lions |
| 18-19 | Braylon Rayson – Sudbury Five Guillaume Boucard – Island Storm Jamal Reynolds – Cape Breton Highlanders Frank Bartley – Saint John Riptide Jaylen Bland – Sudbury Five | Billy White – Moncton Magic Rhamel Brown – Halifax Hurricanes Junior Cadougan – St. John’s Edge Sampson Carter- Island Storm Juan Pattillo – Windsor Express 3rd Mike Poole – Halifax Hurricanes T.J. Maston – Saint John Riptide Akeem Ellis – Kitchener-Waterloo Titan Glen Davis – St. John’s Edge Mo Bolden – London Lightning |
| 19-20 | Antoine Mason – Halifax Xavier Moon – London Jeremiah Mordi – Moncton Braylon Rayson – Sudbury Billy White – Moncton | A.J. Gaines – London Corey Allmond – Moncton Junior Cadougan – St. John’s Jaylen Bland – Sudbury Jairus ‘J.R.’ Holder – Sudbury 3rd Alex Campbell – Island Storm Sam Muldrow – Windsor Cliff Clinkscales – Halifax Chris Jones – Windsor Montay Brandon – St. John’s |
| 20-21 | Season cancelled (covid-19 pandemic) | Season cancelled (covid-19 pandemic) |
| 21-22 | Terry Thomas – London Lightning Joel Kindred – KW Titans Tyran Walker – KW Titans Billy White – Windsor Express Cameron Forte – London Lightning | Jachai Taylor – Windsor Express Eric Ferguson – KW Titans Jeremy Harris – Sudbury Five Jaylen Bland – Sudbury Five Chris Jones – London Lightning |
| 22-23 | Jordan Burns – London Lightning Jeremy Harris – Sudbury Five A.J. Mosby – Sudbury Five Ja’Myrin Jackson – Windsor Express Billy White – Windsor Express | Sam Akano – KW Titans Mike Nuga – London Lightning Terry Thomas – London Lightning J.D. Miller – Sudbury Five Latin Davis – Windsor Express |
| 23-24 | Shadell Millinghaus – Windsor Express A.J. Mosby – Sudbury Five Armani Chaney – Newfoundland Rogues Billy White – London Lightning Curtis Hollis – Kitchener-Waterloo Titans | Marquise Collins – Newfoundland Rogues Jaquan Lightfoot – Kitchener-Waterloo Titans Antoine Mason – Montreal Tundra Jermaine Haley – London Lightning Ty Groce – Windsor Express |
| ALL-PLAYOFF 1ST-TEAM | 2ND | |
| 11-12 | Gabe Freeman – London Lightning Eddie Smith – London Lightning Chris Hagen – Halifax Rainmen Royce Parran – Quebec Kebs Tim Ellis – London Lightning | Tyrone Levett – Halifax Rainmen Shamari Spears – London Lightning Jermaine Blackburn – Saint John Mill Rats Ralphy Holmes – Quebec Kebs Shawn Daniels – London Lightning |
| 12-13 | Rodney Buford – London Lightning Isaac Butts – Moncton Miracles Chris Commons – Windsor Express Jerice Crouch – Saint John Mill Rats Darren Duncan – Windsor Express Elvin Mims – London Lightning Marvin Phillips – London Lightning Kenny Jones – Saint John Mill Rats Brandon Robinson – Summerside Storm Devin Sweetney – Moncton Miracles Josiah Turner – Summerside Storm | |
| 13-14 | Darren Duncan – Windsor Express Stefan Bonneau – Windsor Express Nick Okorie – Island Storm Elvin Mims – London Lightning Jason Williams – Halifax Rainmen | None selected |
| 14-15 | None selected | |
| 15-16 | Stephen Maxwell – London Lightning Mike Glover – Halifax Hurricanes Justin Johnson – Halifax Hurricanes Akeem Scott – London Lightning Brandon Robinson – Windsor Express | |
| 16-17 | Anthony Anderson – Saint John Riptide Ryan Anderson – London Lightning Russell Byrd – Moncton Miracles Jahii Carson – Island Storm Clifford Clinkscales – Halifax Hurricanes Rahlir Hollis-Jefferson – Orangeville A’s Kyle Johnson – London Lightning Maurice Jones – Windsor Express Antoine Mason – Halifax Hurricanes Juan Pattillo – Windsor Express Terry Thomas – Island Storm Royce White – London Lightning Billy White – Halifax Hurricanes Flenard Whitfield – Kitchener-Waterloo Titans | |
| 17-18 | Maurice Bolden – London Lightning Carl English – St. John’s Edge Doug Herring Jr. – London Lightning Charles Hinkle – St. John’s Edge Maurice Jones – Windsor Express Antoine Mason – Halifax Hurricanes Malcolm Miller – Saint John Riptide Kemy Osse – Island Storm Juan Pattillo – Moncton Magic Jaylon Tate – Niagara River Lions Terry Thomas – Moncton Magic Tyrone Watson – Halifax Hurricanes Billy White – Halifax Hurricanes Garrett Williamson – London Lightning | |
| 18-19 | ||
| 19-20 | None selected (covid-19 pandemic) | |
| 20-21 | Season cancelled (covid-19 pandemic) | |
| 21-22 | Jeremy Harris – Sudbury Five Joel Kindred – KW Titans Jesse Jones – KW Titans Chris Jones – London Lightning Terry Thomas – London Lightning | |
| 22-23 | Mike Poole – KW Titans Sam Akano – KW Titans Jeremiah Mordi – London Lightning Jermaine Haley – London Lightning Mike Nuga – London Lightning A.J. Mosby – Sudbury Five J.D. Miller – Sudbury Five Billy White – Windsor Express Latin Davis – Windsor Express Ja’Myrin Jackson – Windsor Express | |
| 23-24 | ||
| ALL-DEFENSIVE | ALL-ROOKIE | |
| 21-22 | Joel Kindred – KW Titans Tyran Walker – KW Titans Amir Williams – London Lightning Billy White – Windsor Express Dexter Williams Jr. – Sudbury Five | Shakwon Barrett – KW Titans Josiah Mastandrea – London Lightning Tyrell Gumbs-Frater – Sudbury Five Kobie Williams – Windsor Express Elijah Ifejeh – Windsor Express |
| 22-23 | 1st Kedar Edwards – KW Titans Cameron Lard – London Lightning Mike Nuga – London Lightning Dexter Williams Jr. – Sudbury Five Billy White – Windsor Express 2nd Jaquan Lightfoot – KW Titans Mike Poole – KW Titans Marcus Ottey – London Lightning J.D. Miller – Sudbury Five Tanner Stuckman – Windsor Express | |
| 23-24 | Omega Harris – Newfoundland Rogues Jaquan Lightfoot – Kitchener-Waterloo Titans William Brown – Newfoundland Rogues Dexter Williams Jr – Kitchener-Waterloo Titans Ty Groce – Windsor Express | Demetrius Barnes – Kitchener-Waterloo Shandarious Cowart – Newfoundland Lewis Djonkam – Newfoundland Montrell Jacobs – Windsor Rashad Smith – London Lightning |