| YEAR | CHAMPION | COACH | RECORD | RUNNER-UP | FINAL |
| 74-75 | LeMoyne-Owen (TENN) | Jerry Johnson | (27-5) | Rowan (NJ) | 57-54 |
| 75-76 | Scranton (Pa) | Bob Bessoir | (29-3) | Wittenberg (O) | 60-57 |
| 76-77 | Wittenberg (O) | Larry Hunter | (23-5) | Oneonta State (NY) | 79-66 |
| 77-78 | North Park (ILL) | Dan McCarrell | (29-2) | Widener (PA) | 69-57 |
| 78-79 | North Park (ILL) | Dan McCarrell | (26-5) | Potsdam State (NY) | 66-62 |
| 79-80 | North Park (ILL) | Dan McCarrell | (28-3) | Upsala (NJ) | 83-76 |
| 80-81 | Potsdam State (NY) | Jerry Welsh | (30-2) | Augustana (ILL) | 67-65 |
| 81-82 | Wabash (IND) | Mac Petty | (24-4) | Potsdam State (NY) | 83-62 |
| 82-83 | Scranton (PA) | Bob Bessoir | (29-3) | Wittenberg (O) | 64-63 |
| 83-84 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | Dave Vander Meulen | (27-4) | Clark (MASS) | 103-86 |
| 84-85 | North Park (ILL) | Bosco Djurickovic | (26-4) | Potsdam State (NY) | 72-71 |
| 85-86 | Potsdam State (NY) | Jerry Welsh | (32-0) | LeMoyne-Owen (TENN) | 76-73 |
| 86-87 | North Park (ILL) | Bosco Djurickovic | (28-3) | Clark (MASS) | 106-100 |
| 87-88 | Ohio Wesleyan | Gene Mehaffey | (27-5) | Scranton (PA) | 92-70 |
| 88-89 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | Dave Vander Meulen | (29-2) | College of New Jersey | 94-86 |
| 89-90 | Rochester (NY) | Mike Neer | (27-5) | DePauw (IND) | 43-42 |
| 90-91 | Wisconsin-Platteville | Bo Ryan | (28-3) | Franklin & Marshall (PA) | 81-74 |
| 91-92 | Calvin (MICH) | Ed Douma | (31-1) | Rochester (NY) | 62-49 |
| 92-93 | Ohio Northern | Joe Campoli | (28-2) | Augustana (ILL) | 71-68 |
| 93-94 | Lebanon Valley (PA) | Pat Flannery | (28-4) | New York University | 66-59 |
| 94-95 | Wisconsin-Platteville | Bo Ryan | (31-0) | Manchester (IND) | 69-55 |
| 95-96 | Rowan (NJ) | John Giannini | (28-4) | Hope (MICH) | 100-93 |
| 96-97 | Illinois Wesleyan | Dennis Bridges | (29-2) | Nebraska Wesleyan | 89-86 |
| 97-98 | Wisconsin-Platteville | Bo Ryan | (30-0) | Hope (MICH) | 69-56 |
| 98-99 | Wisconsin-Platteville | Bo Ryan | (30-2) | Hampden-Sydney (VA) | 76-75 |
| 99-00 | Calvin (MICH) | Kevin Vande Streek | (30-2) | Wisconsin-Eau Claire | 79-75 |
| 00-01 | Catholic (DC) | Mike Lonergan | (28-5) | William Paterson (NJ) | 76-62 |
| 01-02 | Otterbein (O) | Dick Reynolds | (30-3) | Elizabethtown (PA) | 102-83 |
| 02-03 | Williams (PA) | Dave Paulsen | (31-1) | Gustavus Adolphus (MINN) | 67-66 |
| 03-04 | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | Jack Bennett | (29-5) | Williams (PA) | 84-82 |
| 04-05 | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | Jack Bennett | (29-3) | Rochester (NY) | 73-49 |
| 05-06 | Virginia Wesleyan | Dave Macedo | (30-3) | Wittenberg (OHIO) | 59-56 |
| 06-07 | Amherst (MASS) | Dave Hixon | (30-2) | Virginia Wesleyan | 92-84 |
| 07-08 | Washington-St. Louis (MO) | Mark Edwards | (25-6) | Amherst (MASS) | 90-68 |
| 08-09 | Washington-St. Louis (MO) | Mark Edwards | (29-2) | Richard Stockton (NJ) | 71-62 |
| 09-10 | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | Bob Semling | (28-4) | Williams (MASS) | 78-75 |
| 10-11 | St. Thomas (MINN) | Steve Fritz | (30-3) | Wooster (O) | 78-54 |
| 11-12 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | Pat Miller | (29-4) | Cabrini (O) | 63-60 |
| 12-13 | Amherst (MASS) | David Hixon | (30-2) | Mary Hardin-Baylor (TX) | 87-70 |
| 13-14 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | Pat Miller | (29-4) | Williams (MASS) | 75-73 |
| 14-15 | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | Bob Semling | (27-5) | Augustana (ILL) | 70-54 |
| 15-16 | St. Thomas (MINN) | John Tauer | (30-3) | Benedictine (ILL) | 82-76 |
| 16-17 | Babson (MASS) | Stephen Brennan | (31-2) | Augustana (ILL) | 79-78 |
| 17-18 | Nebraska Wesleyan | Dale Wellman | (30-3) | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | 78-72 |
| 18-19 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | Matt Lewis | (29-3) | Swarthmore (PA) | 96-82 |
| 19-20 | SUSPENDED | (covid-19 pandemic) | —– | ————– | —– |
| 20-21 | CANCELLED | (covid-19 pandemic) | —– | ————– | —– |
| 21-22 | Randolph-Macon (VA) | Josh Merkel | (33-1) | Elmhurst (ILL) | 74-45 |
| 22-23 | Christopher Newport (VA) | John Krikorian | (30-3) | Mount Union (O) | 74-72 |
| 23-24 | Trine (IND) | Brooks Miller | 29-4) | Hampden-Sydney (VA) | 69-61 |
| ALL-TOURNAMENT (*denotes MVP) | |||
| 74-75 | *Robert Newman – LeMoyne-Owen Clint Jackson – LeMoyne-Owen Dan Panaggio – Brockport St Bruce Hamming – Augustana (Ill) Greg Ackles – Glassboro St | 75-76 | *Jack Maher – Scranton Tom Dunn – Wittenberg Bob Heubner – Wittenberg Ronnie Wright – Plattsburgh St Terry Lawrence – Augustana (Ill) |
| 76-77 | *Rick White – Wittenberg Phil Smyczek – Hamline Paul Miernicki – Scranton Clyde Eberhardt – Wittenberg Ralph Christian – Oneonta St | 77-78 | *Michael Harper – North Park Dennis James – Widener John Nibert – Albion Earl Keith – Stony Brook St Tom Florentine – North Park |
| 78-79 | *Michael Harper – North Park Don Marsh – Franklin & Marshall Derrick Rowland – Potsdam St Michael Thomas – North Park Modzel Greer – North Park | 79-80 | *Michael Thomas – North Park Ellonya Green – Upsala Steve Keenan – Upsala Tyronne Curtis – Wittenberg Keith French – North Park |
| 80-81 | *Max Artis – Augustana (Ill) Bill Rapier – Augustana (Ill) Ed Jachim – Potsdam St Derrick Rowland – Potsdam St Ron Stewart – Otterbein | 81-82 | *Pete Metzelaars – Wabash Doug Cornfoot – Stanislaus St Rick Davis – Brooklyn Merlin Nice – Wabash Leroy Witherspoon – Potsdam St Maurice Woods – Potsdam St |
| 82-83 | *Bill Bessoir – Scranton Mickey Banas – Scranton Jay Ferguson – Wittenberg (O) Mar Linde – Wisconsin-Whitewater Gerald Holmes – Roanoke | 83-84 | *Andre McKoy – Wisconsin-Whitewater Mark Linde – Wisconsin-Whitewater James Gist – Upsala Dan Trant – Clark (Mass) David Hathway – DePauw (Ind) |
| 84-85 | *Earnest Hubbard – North Park (Ill) Justyne Monegain – North Park (Ill) Dana Janssen – Nebraska Wesleyan Brendan Mitchell – Potsdam St (NY) Lou Stevens – Widener | 85-86 | *Roosevelt Bullock – Potsdam St (NY) Barry Stanton – Potsdam St (NY) Johnny Meyers – Jersey City St Michael Neal – LeMoyne-Owen Dana Janssen – Nebraska Wesleyan |
| 86-87 | *Michael Starks – North Park (Ill) Mike Barch – North Park (Ill) Steve Iannarino – Wittenberg (O) Kermit Sharp – Clark (Mass) Donald Ellison – Richard Stockton | 87-88 | *Scott Tedder – Ohio Wesleyan Lee Rowlinson – Ohio Wesleyan J.P. Andrejko – Scranton (Pa) Charlie Burt – Nebraska Wesleyan Tim McGraw – Hartwick |
| 88-89 | *Greg Grant – Trenton St Danny Johnson – Centre Jeff Bowers – Southern Maine Ricky Spicer – Wisc-Whitewater Elbert Gordon – Wisc-Whitewater Jeff Seifriz – Wisc-Whitewater | 89-90 | *Chris Fite – Rochester (NY) Brett Crist – DePauw (Ind) Chris Brandt – Washington (MD) Brett Hecko – DePauw (Ind) Steve Honderd – Calvin (Mich) |
| 90-91 | *Shawn Frison – Wisc-Platteville James Bradley – Otterbein Robby Jeter – Wisc-Platteville Will Lasky – Franklin & Marshall David Wilding – Franklin & Marshall | 91-92 | *Steve Honderd – Calvin (Mich) Matt Harrison – Calvin (Mich) Mike LeFebre – Calvin (Mich) Chris Fite – Rochester (NY) Kyle Meeker – Rochester (NY) |
| 92-93 | *Kirk Anderson – Augustana (Ill) Mark Gooden – Ohio Northern Aaron Madry – Ohio Northern Steven Haynes – Mass-Dartmouth Keith Wood – Rowan (NJ) | 93-94 | *Mike Rhoades – Lebanon Valley (Pa) *Adam Crawford – New York University Jonathan Gabriel – New York University John Harper – Lebanon Valley (Pa) Matt Croci – Wittenberg (O) |
| 94-95 | *Ernie Peavy – Wisconsin-Platteville Brad Knoy – Manchester Kyle Hupfer – Manchester Aaron Lancaster – Wisconsin-Platteville Charles Grasty – Rowan (NJ) | 95-96 | *Terrence Stewart – Rowan (NJ) Joel Hostege – Hope (MICH) Antwan Dasher – Rowan (NJ) Duane Bosma – Hope (MICH) Chris Simich – Illinois Wesleyan |
| 96-97 | *Bryan Crabtree – Illinois Wesleyan Korey Coon – Illinois Wesleyan Mitch Mosser – Nebraska Wesleyan Damien Hunter – Alvernia Michael Nogelo – Williams | 97-98 | *Ben Hoffman – Wisconsin-Platteville Michael Nogelo – Williams Dave Januzzi – Wilkes Joel Holstege – Hope Andre Dalton – Wisconsin-Platteville |
| 98-99 | *Merrill Brunson – Wisconsin-Platteville Mike Jones – Wisconsin-Platteville T.J. Grimes – Hampden-Sydney (VA) Jeremy Harris – Hampden-Sydney (VA) Horace Jenkins – William Paterson | 99-00 | *Sherm Carstensen – Wisconsin-Eau Claire Jeremy Veenstra – Calvin Aaron Winkle – Calvin Tishuan Jenkins – Salem St Alex Kraft – Franklin & Marshall |
| 00-01 | *Pat Maloney – Catholic Matt Hilleary – Catholic Horace Jenkins – William Paterson Chad Bostelman – Ohio Northern Luke Kasten -Illinois Wesleyan | 01-02 | *Jeff Gibbs – Otterbein Kevin Shay – Otterbein Bob Porambo – Elizabethtown Seth Hauben – Rochester Jason Wiertel – Carthage |
| 02-03 | *Benjamin Coffin – Williams (PA) Michael Crotty – Williams (PA) Doug Espensen – Gustavus Adolphus (MN) Bryan Nelson – Wooster Jeff Monroe – Hampden-Sydney (VA) | 03-04 | *Nick Bennett – Wisconsin-Stevens Point Jason Kalsow – Wisconsin-Stevens Point Tucker Kain – Williams Michael Crotty – Williams Jerry Angel – John Carroll |
| 04-05 | *Jason Kaslow – Wisconsin-Stevens Point Nick Bennett – Wisconsin-Stevens Point Jon Krull – Wisconsin-Stevens Point Seth Hauben – Rochester Joel Hoekstra – Calvin | 05-06 | *Ton Ton Balenga – Va. Wesleyan Keelan Amelianovich-Illinois Wesleyan Dane Borchers – Wittenberg Dan Russ – Wittenberg Brandon Adair – Va. Wesleyan |
| 06-07 | *Andrew Olson – Amherst Tim McLaughlin – Amherst Brandon Adair – Virginia Wesleyan Sean Wallis – Washington University-St. Louis Tim Vandervaart – Wooster | 07-08 | *Troy Ruths – Washington-St. Louis (MO) Andrew Olson – Amherst (MASS) Aaron Thompson – Washington-St. Louis (MO) Derek Van Solkema – Hope (MICH) John Noonan – Ursinus |
| 08-09 | *Sean Wallis – Washington-St. Louis Tyler Nading – Washington-St. Louis Aaron Thompson – Washington-St. Louis Michael Farrow – Richard Stockton James McNally – Franklin & Marshall Clay Henson – Guilford | 09-10 | *Matt Moses – Wisconsin-Stevens Pt. Jared Jenkins – Wisconsin-Stevens Pt. Blake Schultz – Williams Troy Whittington – Williams Tyler Sanborn – Guilford |
| 10-11 | *Tyler Nicolai – St. Thomas (MINN) Tommy Hannon – St. Thomas (MINN) Ian Franks – Wooster (O) Ryan Sharry – Middlebury Nate Robertson – Williams | 11-12 | Eric Bryson – Wisconsin-Whitewater *Chris Davis – Wisconsin-Whitewater John Boyd – Cabrini (O) Jordan Zimmer – Illinois Wesleyan Will Tashman – Massachusetts Institute of Tech |
| 12-13 | *Allen Williamson – Amherst (MASS) Aaron Toomey – Amherst (MASS) James Allen – Mary Hardin-Baylor (TX) Will DeBerg – St. Thomas (MINN) Thomas Orr – Mary Hardin-Baylor (TX) Landon Gamble – North Central (ILL) | 13-14 | *K.J. Evans – Wisconsin-Whitewater Quandell Young – Wisconsin-Whitewater Eric Bryson – Wisconsin-Whitewater Duncan Robinson – Williams Mike Mayer – Williams |
| 14-15 | *Austin Ryf – Wisconsin-Stevens Point Stephen Pelkofer – Wisconsin-Stevens Point Joe Ritchay – Wisconsin-Stevens Point Hunter Hill – Augustana (ILL) Joey Flannery – Babson | 15-16 | *Taylor Montero – St. Thomas (MINN) Grant Schaeffer – St. Thomas (MINN) Ryan Saarela – St. Thomas (MINN) Luke Johnson – Benedictine (ILL) Connor Green – Amherst (MASS) |
| 16-17 | *Joey Flannery – Babson (MASS) Isaiah Nelsen – Babson (MASS) Nolan Ebel – Augustana (ILL) Chrishawn Orange – Augustana (ILL) Daniel Aronowitz – Williams (MASS) | 17-18 | *Cooper Cook – Nebraska Wesleyan Nate Schimonitz – Nebraska Wesleyan Ben Boots – Wisconsin-Oshkosh Brett Wittchow – Wisconsin Oshkosh Jack Hiller – Nebraska Wesleyan |
| 18-19 | *Jack Flynn – Wisconsin-Oshkosh Cam Wiley – Swarthmore (PA) Zac O’Dell – Swarthmore (PA) Adam Fravet – Wisconsin-Oshkosh Aston Francis – Wheaton (ILL) | 19-20 | None selected (suspended, covid-19 pandemic) |
| 20-21 | None selected (cancelled, covid-19 pandemic) | 21-22 | *Buzz Anthony – Randolph-Macon (VA) Miles Mallory – Randolph-Macon (VA) Jake Rhode – Elmhurst (ILL) Lukas Islay – Marietta (O) Jack Davison – Wabash (IND) |
| 22-23 | *Trey Barber – Christopher Newport Jahn Hines – Christopher Newport Christian Parker – Mount Union Collen Gurley – Mount Union Trey Barber – Christopher Newport George Visconti – Swarthmore | 23-24 | *Cortez Garland – Trine (IND) Nate Tucker – Trine (IND) Aidan Smylie – Trine (IND) Adam Brazil – Hampden-Sydney (VA) Julius Burch – Guilford |