| YEAR | CHAMPION | COACH | RECORD | RUNNER-UP | FINAL |
| 0809 | Old Dominion Etoile Ibama | Blaine Taylor | (25-10) | Bradley David Collins | 66-62 |
| 09-10 | Missouri State | Cuonzo Martin | (24-12) | Pacific | 78-65 |
| 10-11 | Santa Clara Julian Clarke Marc Trasolini | Kerry Keating | (24-13) | Iona Randy Dezouvre | 76-69 |
| 11-12 | Mercer | Bob Hoffman | (27-11) | Utah State | 70-67 |
| 12-13 | East Carolina | Jeff Lebo | (23-12) | Weber State | 77-74 |
| 13-14 | Murray State | Steve Prohm | (23-11) | Yale | 65-57 |
| 14-15 | Evansville | Marty Simmons | (24-12) | Northern Arizona | 71-65 |
| 15-16 | Columbia Chris McComber | Kyle Smith | (25-10) | Cal-Irvine | 73-67 |
| 16-17 | Saint Peter’s | John Dunne | (23-13) | Texas A&M-Corpus Christi Kareem South | 62-61 |
| 17-18 | Northern Colorado | Jeff Linder | (26-12) | Illinois-Chicago Godwin Boahen Marcus Ottey | 76-71 |
| 18-19 | Marshall | Dan D’Antoni | (23-14) | Green Bay | 90-70 |
| 19-20 | CANCELLED | (covid-19 pandemic) | —– | ———– | —– |
| 20-21 | CANCELLED | (covid-19 pandemic) | —– | ———– | —– |
| 21-22 | Fresno State | Justin Hutson | (23-13) | Coastal Carolina Rudi Williams Isaac Hippolyte | 85-74 |
| 22-23 | CANCELLED | ——————– | —– | ———– | —– |
| 23-24 | Norfolk State | Robert Jones | (24-11) | Purdue-Fort Wayne | 75-67 |
| ALL-TOURNEY (*denotes MVP) | |||
| 08-09 | *Frank Hassell – Old Dominion Erik Kangas – Oakland Gerald Lee – Old Dominion Sam Maniscalco – Bradley Marsharee Neely – Old Dominion Chris Roberts – Bradley Theron Wilson – Bradley | ||
| 09-10 | *Will Creekmore – Missouri State Adam Leonard – Missouri State Kyle Weems – Missouri State Joe Ford – Pacific Sam Willard – Pacific Donald Sims – Appalachian State Anthony Johnson – Fairfield | 10-11 | *Kevin Foster – Santa Clara Papa Dia – SMU Mike Glover –Iona Scott Machado – Iona Troy Payne – Santa Clara Mike Smith – East Tennessee State Marc Trasolini – Santa Clara |
| 11-12 | Pane Brockeith – Utah State Justin Cecil – Mercer Morgan Grim – Utah State *Langston Hall – Mercer Reggie Hamilton – Oakland Preston Medlin – Utah State Travis Smith – Mercer | 12-13 | *Maurice Kemp – East Carolina Miguel Paul – East Carolina Robert Sampson – East Carolina Frank Otis – Weber State Scott Bamforth – Weber State Kyle Tresnak – Weber State Seth Tuttle – Northern Iowa Colt Ryan – Evansville |
| 13-14 | *Cameron Payne – Murray State Jarvis Williams – Murray State Justin Sears – Yale Javier Duren – Yale D.J. Covington – VMI Tony Gill – Pacific | 14-15 | *D.J. Balentine – Evansville Egidijus Mockevicius – Evansville Adam Wing – Evansville Aaseem Dixon – Northern Arizona Quinton Upshur – Northern Arizona Kris Yanku – Northern Arizona |
| 15-16 | *Maolo Lo – Columbia Grant Mullins – Columbia Alex Rosenberg – Columbia Mike Best – Cal-Irvine Alex Young – Cal-Irvine Elijah Wilson – Coastal Carolina Damon Lynn – NJIT HM Luke Petrasek – Columbia Luke Nelson – Cal-Irvine Ken Coleman – NJIT Grandy Glaze – Grand Canyon | 16-17 | *Quadir Welton – St. Peter’s Chris Acox – Furman Ehab Amin – Texas A&M-Corpus Christi Chris Clemons – Campbell Will Darley – MD-Baltimore County Rashawn Thomas – Texas A&M-Corpus Christi Trevis Wyche – Saint Peter’s |
| 17-18 | *Andre Spight – Northern Colorado ‘ Jordan Davis – Northern Colorado Tarkus Ferguson – Illinois-Chicago Chris Galbreath Jr – Sam Houston State Tai Odiase – Illinois-Chicago Marcus Ottey – Illinois-Chicago Jonah Radebaugh – Northern Colorado | 18-19 | Tyrik Armstrong – Texas Southern Trevond Barnes – Hampton *C.J. Burks – Marshall Sandy Cohen III – Green Bay Jeremy Combs – Texas Southern Jon Elmore – Marshall ShanQuan Hemphill – Green Bay Taevion Kinsey – Marshall |
| 19-20 | None selected (cancelled, covid-19 pandemic) | 20-21 | None selected (cancelled, covid-19 pandemic) |
| 21-22 | *Orlando Robinson – Fresno State Destin Whitaker – Fresno State Leo Colimerio – Fresno State Isaiah Hill – Fresno State Rudi Williams – Coastal Carolina Vince Cole – Coastal Carolina Ibrima Dibba – Coastal Carolina | 22-23 | CANCELLED |
| 23-24 | *Christian Ings – Norfolk State |