| YEAR | CHAMPION | COACH | RECORD | RUNNER-UP | FINAL |
| 07-08 | Tulsa | Doug Wojcik | (25-14) | Bradley David Collins | 2g-1 |
| 08-09 | Oregon State | Craig Robinson | (18-18) | U.T.E.P. | 75-69; 63-70; 81-73 |
| 09-10 | Virginia Commonwealth | Shaka Smart | (27-9) | St. Louis | 68-56; 71-65 |
| 10-11 | Oregon | Dana Altman | (21-18) | Creighton Jahenns Manigat | 76-84; 71-58; 71-69 |
| 11-12 | Pittsburgh Khem Birch | Jamie Dixon | (22-17) | Washington State | 66-67; 57-53; 71-65 |
| 12-13 | Santa Clara Julian Clarke | Kerry Keating | (26-12) | George Mason | 81-73; 66-73; 80-77 |
| 13-14 | Siena | Jimmy Patsos | (20-18) | Fresno State Emmanuel Owootoah | 61-57; 75-89; 81-68 |
| 14-15 | Loyola-Ill | Porter Moser | (24-13) | Louisiana-Monroe | 65-58; 63-62 |
| 15-16 | Nevada | Eric Musselman | (24-14) | Morehead State | 83-86; 77-68; 85-82 |
| 16-17 | Wyoming | Allen Edwards | (23-15) | Coastal Carolina Amidou Bamba | 81-91; 81-57; 83-59 |
| 17-18 | North Texas | Grant McCasland | (20-18) | San Francisco | 62-72; 69-55; 88-77 |
| 18-19 | South Florida | Brian Gregory | (24-14) | DePaul | 63-61; 96-100; 77-65 |
| 19-20 | CANCELLED | (covid-19 pandemic) | —– | —— | —————- |
| 20-21 | Pepperdine | Lorenzo Romar | (15-12) | Coastal Carolina | 84-61 |
| 21-22 | UNC-Wilmington | Takayo Siddle | (27-9) | Middle Tennessee | 96-90 |
| 22-23 | Charlotte | Ron Sanchez | (22-14) | Eastern Kentucky | 71-68 |
| 23-24 | Seattle | Chris Victor | (23-14) | High Point | 77-67 |
| ALL-TOURNAMENT | |||
| 07-08 |
*Jerome
Jordan – Tulsa Jeremy Crouch – Bradley Ben Uzoh – Tulsa Sean Singletary – Virginia Rob McKiver – Houston | 08-09 |
*Roeland
Schaftenaar – Oregon State Stefon Jackson – UTEP Randy Culpepper – UTEP Lathen Wallace – Oregon State Daniel Gonzalvez – Richmond |
| 09-10 | *Joey Rodriguez – V.C.U. None selected | 10-11 | *Joevan Catron – Oregon None selected |
| 11-12 | *Lamar Patterson – Pittsburgh None selected | 12-13 | *Kevin Foster – Santa Clara None selected |
| 13-14 | *Brent Bisping – Siena None selected | 14-15 | *Earl Peterson – Loyola-Ill None selected |
| 15-16 | *Tyron Criswell – Nevada None selected | 16-17 | *Justin James – Wyoming None selected |
| 17-18 | *Roosevelt Smart – North Texas None selected | 18-19 | *David Collins – South Florida None selected |
| 19-20 | None selected (cancelled, covid-19 pandemic) | 20-21 | *Kessler Edwards – Pepperdine None selected |
| 21-22 | *Jaylen Sims – UNC-Wilmington Mike Okauru – UNC-Wilmington Donovan Sims – Middle Tennessee Dayln Kountz – Northern Colorado Coryon Mason – Abilene Christian | 22-23 | *Brice Williams – Charlotte Devontae Blanton- Eastern Kentucky Isaiah Cozart – Eastern Kentucky Tevian Jones- Southern Utah BJ Freeman- Milwaukee |
| 23-24 | *Cameron Tyson – Seattle Alex Schumacher – Seattle Juslin Bodo Bodo – High Point Kezza Giffa – High Point Izaiyah Nelson – Arkansas State |