| YEAR | ALL-TOURNEY/ALL-LEAGUE (*denotes MVP) |
| 03-04 | *Nathan Clarke – Charlottetown Rural Matt MacMillan – Colonel Gray Zack White – Montague Cameron MacAskill – Charlottetown Rural Jordan Richard – Three Oaks Morgan Carlile – Three Oaks |
| 04-05 | *Jeremy MacKinnon – Hampshire Bluefield Cameron McAskill – Charlottetown Rural Alex Campbell – Three Oaks Brandon Watters – Charlottetown Colonel Gray Jordan Drake – Charlottetown Colonel Gray Paul Killorn – Hampshire Bluefield |
| 05-06 | *Tim Butler – Colonel Gray Zach White – Montague Steve Hardy – Three Oaks Mitch Eamer – Charlottetown Rural Tim Kalinowski – Colonel Gray Jacob Ayangama – Colonel Gray |
| 06-07 | *Jacob Ayangama – Colonel Gray Blair Harrell – Three Oaks Stuart Wright – Charlottetown Rural Robbie McSwain – Col Gray Jason McAlduff – Hampshire Bluefield Nic Jones – Hampshire Bluefield |
| 07-08 | *Aaron Robbins – Charlottetown Rural Jason MacLean – Hampshire Bluefield Matt Morrison – Colonel Gray Sean Bradley – Three Oaks Mike Hardy – Three Oaks Nathan Palmer – Charlottetown Rural |
| 08-09 | *Ryan Lloyd – Charlottetown Rural Kylie Ballie – Three Oaks Logan Dawson – Hampshire Bluefield Evan Barwise – Charlottetown Rural Kevin MacLeod – Colonel Gray-1 Greg Morrison – Colonel Gray-1 |
| 09-10 | *Kyle Gillis – Charlottetown Rural-1 Andrew Woodside – Bluefield Kevin MacLeod – Colonel Gray Will Brawn – Three Oaks Jacob Simmons – Charlottetown Rural-1 Aaron Robbins – Charlottetown Rural-1 |
| 10-11 | *Mark Matheson – Three Oaks Kevin MacLeod – Colonel Gray Kyle Welton – Charlottetown Rural Jacob Simmons – Charlottetown Rural Brett Montgomery – Three Oaks Dexter Coughlin – Three Oaks |
| 11-12 | *Mark Matheson – Three Oaks Kenan Wilkie – Westisle Mike Mackenzie – Colonel Gray Alec Parise – Three Oaks Dylan Gallant – Three Oaks Kyle Welton – Charlottetown Rural |
| 12-13 | *Noah Giddings – Rural Zack Marsh – Bluefield Colin Arsenault – Three Oaks Jeff Morrison – Gray Stephen Seviour – Rural Mike MacKenzie – Gray |
| 13-14 | *Stephen Seviour – Charlottetown Rural Tanner Mendoza – Three Oaks Logan MacDonald – Charlottetown Rural Brayden White – Charlottetown Rural Brett Butler – Colonel Gray Jeremy Thompson – Colonel Gray |
| 14-15 | *Logan MacDonald – Charlottetown Rural Brian Mahoney – Bluefield Jack MacAulay – Charlottetown Rural Jeremy Thompson – Charlottetown Colonel Gray Max Ramsay – Charlottetown Colonel Gray Matt Tanton – Three Oaks |
| 15-16 | *Alex Campbell – Colonel Gray Adam Ryan – Charlottetown Rural Isaac Kirkland – Charlottetown Rural Yousef Sefau – Colonel Gray Conner Herget – Westisle Matt Tanton – Three Oaks |
| 16-17 | *Alex Campbell – Colonel Gray-1 Jacob Rayner – Westisle. Logan MacDougall – Three Oaks-1 Adam Ryan – Rural-1 Jordan Reid – Colonel Gray-1 Matt Connolly – Colonel Gray-1 |
| 17-18 | *Ethan Boyd – Three Oaks-1 Logan MacCallum – Rural-1 Zack Wall – Rural-1 Logan Cameron – Three Oaks-1 Ben MacDougall – Three Oaks-1 Jesse Fleming – Colonel Gray-1 League 1st Ethan Boyd – Three Oaks-1 Logan Cameron – Three Oaks-1 Logan MacCallum – Rural-1 Ben MacDougall – Three Oaks-2 John Alex Vos – Gray-1 Zack Wall – Rural-1 2nd Josh Bourque – Rural-1 Josh Fall – Bluefield Jonny Mackenzie – Gray-1 Joe Thompson – Gray-1 Ryan Thompson – Gray-1 |
| 18-19 | *Logan MacCallum – Charlottetown Rural Chris Ramsey – Westisle Ian Kerr – Colonel Gray Parker Roche – Three Oaks Vlersam Musliu – Three Oaks Ben MacDougall – Three Oaks League 1st Ian Kerr – Col Gray Logan MacCallum – Rural Ben MacDougall – TOSH Parker Roche – Rural Yahya Sefau – Col Gray League 2nd Justin Caron – TOSH Thomas Hogan – Rural Vlersim Musliu – TOSH Chris Ramsay – WI Sahib Singh – TOSH Will Vidito – Rural |
| 19-20 | *Ben MacDougall – Three Oaks-1 Matthew Smith – Westisle-1 Charlie Turner – Three Oaks-1 Kalen MacDonald-Wood – Rural-1 Justin Caron – Three Oaks-1 Jose Chrisostomo – Rural-1 LEAGUE 1ST Jose Crisostomo – Rural-1 Ben MacDougall – Three Oaks-1 Vlersin Musliu – Three Oaks-1 Chris Ramsay – Westisle-1 Sahib Singh – Three Oaks-1 2nd Ian Kerr – Colonel Gray-1 Kalen MacDonald-Wood – Rural-1 Jeremy Norman – Colonel Gray-1 Mathew Smith – Westisle-1 Thomas Yeo – Bluefield-1 |
| 20-21 | None selected (cancelled, covid-19 pandemic) |
| 21-22 | *Zach Blood – Three Oaks Nate Whitnell – Colonel Gray Jordan Gough – Westisle Kalon MacDonald- Wood – Rural Ryan MacKinnon – Three Oaks Armaan Singh – Three Oaks |
| 22-23 | *Nate Whitnell – Colonel Gray-1 John Ikpotokin – Colonel Gray-1 Kallen Power – Rural-1 Demmoy Dozoovado – Rural-1 Brock Brink – Westisle Jordan Gough – Westisle Faik Iskfi – Three Oaks-1 Coulton MacDougall – Bluefield-1 |
| 23-24 | Brock Brink – Westisle-1 Brayden Bruce – Colonel Gray-1 Seth Gauthier – Colonel Gray-1 Matthew Gorrill – Westisle-1 Gabe Ing – Charlottetown Rural-1 Faik Isufi – Three Oaks-1 Coulton MacDougall – Bluefield-1 Aiden Rossiter – Three Oaks-1 Kyler Vaive – Colonel Gray-1 |