| YEAR | ALL-TOURNEY/ALL-LEAGUE |
| 03-04 | *Erin Kinsman – Charlottetown Rural Lisa McIver – Hampshire Bluefield Victoria Walker – Three Oaks Suzanne MacMillan – Colonel Gray Barb Vriends – Charlottetown Rural Susanne Canvin – Colonel Gray |
| 04-05 | *Cassie Goodwin – Charlottetown Colonel Gray Lisa McIver – Hampshire Bluefield Erin Kinsman – Charlottetown Rural Suzanne Canvin – Charlottetown Colonel Gray Megan MacDonald – Three Oaks Caitlin Carota – Three Oaks |
| 05-06 | *Susanne Canvin – Colonel Gray Meaghan MacQuaid – Souris Kirsten Walker – Colonel Gray Shannon Noonan – Three Oaks Katie Moore – Colonel Gray Sara Moore – Charlottetown Rural |
| 06-07 | *Carly LaFave – Colonel Gray Ashley McGuigan – Charlottetown Rural Santana Wedge – Elmsdale Westisle Kirsten Walker – Col Gray Jane Mckillop – Three Oaks Katie Moore – Col Gray |
| 07-08 | *Carly Lafave – Colonel Gray Sara Moore – Charlottetown Rural Kristine Johnston – Three Oaks Ashley Howell – Three Oaks Carolyn McKenna – Colonel Gray Julia McKenna – Colonel Gray |
| 08-09 | *Julia McKenna – Colonel Gray-1 Shannon Moore – Hampshire Bluefield-1 Allyson Seviour – Charlottetown Rural-1 Cierra Gaudet – Three Oaks-1 Ashley Howell – Three Oaks-1 Maggie Musclow – Colonel Gray-1 |
| 09-10 | *Catherine Strongman – Three Oaks-1 Tressa Lloyd – Charlottetown Rural Brittany MacLean – Bluefield Kristine Johnston – Three Oaks Melanie McKenna – Colonel Gray Kristen Callaghan – Colonel Gray |
| 10-11 | *Maiqi Li – Colonel Gray Samantha Rioux – Three Oaks Brittany MacLean – Bluefield Sarah Essery – Colonel Gray Jessica Patenaude – Charlottetown Rural Tressa Lloyd – Charlottetown Rural |
| 11-12 | *Madison Tompkins – Three Oaks Jessica Patenaude – Charlottetown Rural Breanna Gallant – Westisle Haley Butler – Colonel Gray Erica Gillis – Three Oaks Kiera Rigby – Colonel Gray |
| 12-13 | *Jaime MacLean – Three Oaks Jessica Patenaude – Rural Victoria Barbour – Gray Charlotte Thompson – Three Oaks Madison Blanchard – Gray Erica Gillis – Three Oaks |
| 13-14 | *Jenna Mae Ellsworth – Colonel Gray Haley Wilting – Bluefield Jessica Gillis – Three Oaks Ashley Simmons – Three Oaks Kendra Craswell – Colonel Gray Jada Yeo – Colonel Gray |
| 14-15 | *Jenna Mae Ellsworth – Charlottetown Colonel Gray Haley Wilting – Bluefield Lexi MacInnis – Charlottetown Rural Julie Campbell – Three Oaks Kendra Craswell – Charlottetown Colonel Gray Jada Yeo – Charlottetown Colonel Gray |
| 15-16 | *Ashley Plaggenhoef – Charlottetown Rural Lexi MacInnis – Charlottetown Rural Jenna Mae Ellsworth – Colonel Gray Jada Yeo – Colonel Gray Zoie Farish – Montague Nikki Arsenault – Three Oaks |
| 16-17 | *Lexi MacInnis – Rural-1 Madison MacKinnon – Westisle Sam Strain – Colonel Gray-1 Ashley Plaggenhoef – Rural-1 Callie MacDonald – Three Oaks-1 Nikki Arsenault – Three Oaks-1 |
| 17-18 | *Sydney Whitlock – Rural-1 Devon Lawlor – Rural-1 Maddie Hurley – Rural-1 Lauren Reid – Rural-1 Francis Alvarez – Colonel Gray-1 Lyndsay Callaghan – Westisle-1 League 1st Francis Alverez – Gray-1 Devon Lawlor – Rural-1 Georgie McKenna – Three Oaks-1 Ashley Plaggenhoef – Rural-1 Sydney Whitlock – Rural-1 2nd Rylee Connolly – Gray-1 Lauren Lilly – Three Oaks-1 Gemma Shea – Westisle Sam Strain – Gray-1 Helena Vos – Gray-1 |
| 18-19 | *Devon Lawlor – Rural-1 Makayla Vos – Bluefield-1 Sydney Strain – Colonel Gray-1 Lauren Lilly – Three Oaks-1 Amy Plaggenhoef – Rural-1 League 1st Elesea Glenn – Bluefield Devon Lawlor – Rural Lauren Lilly – TOSH Amy Plaggenhoef – Rural Mackayla Vos – Bluefield League 2nd Paige Campbell – TOSH Julia Freeburn – Rural Sydney Strain – Col Gray Rylee Connolly – Col Gray Emma Seviour – Rural |
| 19-20 | *Devon Lawlor – Rural-1 Helena Vos – Colonel Gray-1 Taylor Mitton – Rural-1 Paige MacLean – Three Oaks-1 Amy Plaggenhoef – Rural-1 Lauren Lilly – Three Oaks-1 LEAGUE 1ST Devon Lawlor – Rural-1 Lauren Lilly – Three Oaks-1 Amy Plaggenhoef – Rural-1 McKayla Vos – Bluefield-1 Helena Vos – Colonel Gray-1 2nd Elesea Glenn – Bluefield-1 Sydney Lawlor – Rural-1 Megan MacDonald – Three Oaks-1 Paige MacLean – Three Oaks-1 Taylor Mitton – Rural-1 Grace Morrison – Bluefield-1 Kathleen Ryan – Montague |
| 20-21 | None selected (cancelled, covid-19 pandemic) |
| 21-22 | *Sydney Lawlor – Rural Sara Hanlon – Colonel Gray Ashley Cullen – Bluefield Paige MacLean – Three Oaks Katie Vidito – Rural Isabelle McGeoghegan – Rural |
| 22-23 | *Isabelle McGeoghegan – Rural-1 Menna McCabe – Rural-1 Zoe Olscamp – Rural-1 Victoria Zakem – Gray-1 Sara Hanlon – Gray-1 Avery Kerwin – Three Oaks-1 Dru Gillis- Three Oaks-1 Sophie Leclair – Bluefield-1 |
| 23-24 | Juliette Bader – Colonel Gray-1 Katelyn Brothers – Montague Sophie Campbell – Montague Dru Gillis – Three Oaks-1 Jadyn Huggan – Charlottetown Rural-1 Naomi Ikpotokin – Colonel Gray-1 Sophie Leclair – Bluefield-1 Molly McCourt – Bluefield-1 Rebekah McGeoghegan – Charlottetown Rural-1 Alex Newson – Charlottetown Rural-1 Zoe Olscamp – Charlottetown Rural-1 |