| YEAR | CHAMPION | COACH | FINAL | RUNNER-UP |
| 49-50 | West Kent | Neil Young | (2g-0) | Summerside |
| 50-51 | ||||
| 51-52 | ||||
| 52-53 | ||||
| 53-54 | ||||
| 54-55 | ||||
| 55-56 | ||||
| 56-57 | ||||
| 57-58 | ||||
| 58-59 | Prince of Wales | Bob LeClair | (2g-0) | Summerside |
| 59-60 | Prince of Wales | Bob LeClair | (2g-0) | Summerside |
| 60-61 | Prince of Wales | Bob LeClair | ||
| 61-62 | Summerside | |||
| 62-63 | Summerside | Mrs. M Ferguson | (2g-0) | Prince of Wales |
| 63-64 | Summerside | Prince of Wales | ||
| 64-65 | Summerside | Charlie Ballem | ||
| 65-66 | Prince of Wales | Helen Bishop | Summerside | |
| 66-67 | Prince of Wales | 39-17 | Morell | |
| 67-68 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray | |||
| 68-69 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray | |||
| 69-70 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray | |||
| 70-71 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray | Diamond | 108-18 | Charlottetown Rural |
| 71-72 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray | |||
| 72-73 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray | Gadd | ||
| 73-74 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray | Gadd | 50-36 | Charlottetown Rural |
| 74-75 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray | Irvine | 37-24 | Charlottetown Rural |
| 75-76 | Morell | George Morrison | 35-29 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray |
| 76-77 | Morell | George Morrison | 56-42 | Charlottetown Rural |
| 77-78 | Summerside Three Oaks | Charlottetown Colonel Gray | ||
| 78-79 | Morell Regional | George Morrison | Summerside Three Oaks | |
| 79-80 | Kensington | Summerside Three Oaks | ||
| 80-81 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray | Glen Edison | Summerside Three Oaks | |
| 81-82 | Summerside Three Oaks | Garth Turtle | ||
| 82-83 | Morell | Rick Millard | Summerside Three Oaks | |
| 83-84 | Summerside Three Oaks | Larry Wright | Charlottetown Rural | |
| 84-85 | Summerside Three Oaks | Larry Wright | ||
| 85-86 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray | Chris Annett/ Bruce Norton | 38-36 | Kensington |
| 86-87 | Summerside Three Oaks | Larry Wright | 80-55 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray |
| 87-88 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray | Chris Annett | 39-37 | Charlottetown Rural |
| 88-89 | Charlottetown Rural | Mike Lloyd | 72-55 | Summerside Three Oaks |
| 89-90 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray | Chris Annett | 65-37 | Kensington |
| 90-91 | Charlottetown Rural | Mike Lloyd | 45-35 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray |
| 91-92 | Charlottetown Rural | Mike Lloyd | 55-49 | Summerside Three Oaks |
| 92-93 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray | Chris Annett | 73-45 | Summerside Three Oaks |
| 93-94 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray | Chris Annett | 71-52 | Summerside Three Oaks |
| 94-95 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray | Chris Annett | 52-22 | Summerside Three Oaks |
| 95-96 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray | Chris Annett | 82-61 | Elmsdale Westisle |
| 96-97 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray | Chris Annett | 70-41 | Charlottetown Rural |
| 97-98 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray-AA | Chris Annett | 53-36 | Charlottetown Rural-AA |
| 98-99 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray-AA | Chris Annett | 50-40 | Charlottetown Rural-AA |
| 99-00 | Charlottetown Rural | Mike Lloyd | 54-43 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray |
| 00-01 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray | Chris Annett | 60-41 | Charlottetown Rural |
| 01-02 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray | Chris Annett | 45-48 | Charlottetown Rural |
| 02-03 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray | Chris Annett | 47-36 | Summerside Three Oaks |
| 03-04 | Kensington | Anna Stammberger | 44-41 | Montague |
| 04-05 | Elmsdale Westisle | Dana Gard/ Mary Reid | 67-62 | Souris |
| 05-06 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray-2 | Paul McInnis | 35-33 | Elmsdale Westisle |
| 06-07 | Souris | 49-39 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray-2 | |
| 07-08 | Elmsdale Westisle | Dana Gard | 70-37 | Morell |
| 08-09 | Morell | 54-50 | Elmsdale Westisle | |
| 09-10 | Morell | Jordan McNally | 78-61 | Souris |
| 10-11 | Summerside Three Oaks-2 | Debbie Miller/ Shelly Lilly | 60-52 | Elmsdale Westisle |
| 11-12 | Bluefield | 72-70 | Summerside Three Oaks-2 | |
| 12-13 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray-2 | 66-60 | Bluefield | |
| 13-14 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray-2 | 63-59 | Westisle | |
| 14-15 | Kensington | Michelle Hickey | 45-33 | Summerside Three Oaks-2 |
| 15-16 | Kensington | Brooke Johnston | 55-46 | Elmsdale Westisle |
| 16-17 | Charlottetown Grace Christian | 46-40 | Bluefield-1 | |
| 17-18 | Bluefield-1 | Stephen Letner | 59-44 | Kensington |
| 18-19 | Montague | David Boyce | 57-45 | Charlottetown Grace Christian |
| 19-20 | Charlottetown Rural-2 | Trisha Banks/ Emily McIsaac | 73-46 | Elmsdale Westisle-1 |
| 20-21 | CANCELLED | (covid-19 pandemic) | —– | ————————– |
| 21-22 | Montague Regional | Duane Yoshikawa | 75-60 | Charlottetown Rural-2 |
| 22-23 | Montague Regional | Duane Yoshikawa | 71-61 | Charlottetown Rural-2 |
| 23-24 | Charlottetown Rural-2 | Emily MacIsaac | 29-28 | Hampshire Bluefield-2 |