| YEAR | CHAMPION | COACH | FINAL | RUNNER-UP |
| 46-47 | Charlottetown West Kent | |||
| 47-48 | Charlottetown West Kent | Neil Young | 2-0-1 | Charlottetown Prince Street |
| 48-49 | ||||
| 49-50 | Charlottetown West Kent | Neil Young | T:61-19 | Summerside |
| 50-51 | Charlottetown Prince Street | —– | No challenger | |
| 51-52 | Charlottetown Prince Street | 26-23 | Charlottetown West Kent | |
| 52-53 | Charlottetown Prince Street | 2g-1 | Charlottetown West Kent | |
| 53-54 | Charlottetown Prince Street | Jack Ross | 29-28 | Rochford Square |
| 54-55 | Queen Charlotte | Rochford | ||
| 55-56 | Charlottetown West Kent | |||
| 56-57 | Queen Charlotte | |||
| 57-58 | Queen Charlotte | |||
| 58-59 | Queen Charlotte | |||
| 59-60 | Queen Charlotte | |||
| 60-61 | Birchwood | |||
| 61-62 | Birchwood | |||
| 62-63 | Birchwood | |||
| 63-64 | Queen Charlotte | |||
| 64-65 | Queen Charlotte | |||
| 65-66 | Queen Charlotte | |||
| 66-67 | Queen Charlotte | |||
| 67-68 | Miscouche | |||
| 68-69 | Summerside | |||
| 69-70 | ||||
| 70-71 | ||||
| 71-72 | ||||
| 72-73 | ||||
1947
The champion Charlottetown West Kent: Heather Lantz; Hilda Pickard; Lorna Chandler; Valerie Rogers; Joan Stewart; Phyllis Cutcliffe; Jean MacArthur; Joan Wood;
1948
In the provincial finals, Charlottetown West Kent defeated Charlottetown Prince Street in a best of three final. West Kent won the first game. The second was tied and in the third, West Kent prevailed 23-13. In game three, West Kent prevailed 23-13 as Jean MacArthur scored 10, Phyllis Cutcliff 7, Winnie MacKenzie 6 and Heather Lantz 2. S McKarris and Peggy Campbell each scored 6 to lead Prince Street. McManus added 1.
The runner-up Charlottetown Prince Street: S McKarris; Peggy Campbell; McManus; Joan Storey; A Bulmer; McEwen; T Barwise; MacNevin; Whitehead; Brown; MacLaren;
The champion Charlottetown West Kent: Sylvia Sterns; Anita Lynds; Jean MacArthur; Olga Jenkins; Ruby MacKinnon; Shirley Campbell; Heather Lantz; Winnie MacKenzie; Joan Stewart; Phyllis Cutcliffe; coach Neil Young
1949
1950
In the Charlottetown city final, West Kent defeated Prince Street 30-12; 23-27 (Total: 53-39). …………………………………………………… In game one, West Kent prevailed 30-12 as Claudette MacMillan scored 18, Jane Giddings 8 Eileen MacArthur 4 and Jo-Ann MacDonald 4. Joan MacKinnon paced Prince Street with 8. Joan Tanton added 2, Peggy Campbell 1 and Edith Smith 1, while Donna Bowness, Jean Diamond and Marjorie Hurst were scoreless. Prince Street as coached by Keith Dalziel. …………………………………………………… In game two, Prince Street prevailed 27-23 as Peggy Campbell scored 20, Joan MacKinnon 5 and Joan Tanton 2, while Donna Bowness, Huestis and Jean Diamond were scoreless. Claudette MacMillan paced West Kent with 10. Helen Whitlock added 6, Dorothy Simmonds 2, Eileen MacArthur 2, Joanne MacDonald 2 and Jane Giddings 1.
In the finals, West Kent defeated Summerside 34-7; 27-12 (Total: 61-21).
In game one, West Kent blasted Summerside 34-7 after leading 16-4 at the half. Eileen MacArthur paced West Kent with 8. Eileen Guindon added 7, Claudette MacMillan 6, Helen Whitlock 5, Jane Giddings 4, Eleanor Storey 2 and Dorothy Simmonds 2. Junie Meike and Betty Inman each scored 3 to lead Summerside. Clark added 1.
In game two, West Kent prevailed 27-12 as Claudette MacMillan scored 17, Eileen MacArthur 5 and Jane Giddings 3. Shirley Burns paced Summerside with 8. Betty Inman added 2.
The runner-up Summerside: Junie Meikle; D Dewar; G Clark; Betty Inman; M Elderkin; Shirley Burns; M Smith; M Inman;
The champion West Kent: Jane Giddings; Eleanor Storey; Helen Stewart; Arlene Guindon; Helen Taweel; Joanne MacDonald; Eileen MacArthur; Claudette MacMillan; Helen Whitlock; Dorothy Simmonds; Jean MacGuire; coach Neil Young
1951
Charlottetown Prince Street wins the city title. There is no challenger (Summerside declined) so they are awarded the Interscholastic provincial crown.
The champion Charlottetown Prince Street: Claudette McMillan, Mary Worthy, Elaine Murphy, Edie Smith, Dawn Messer, Pickard, Barbara Wran, Perry, Helen Whitlock
1952
In the final, Charlottetown Prince Street defeated Charlottetown West Kent 26-23 as B Whitlock scored 14, Barbara Wran 6, Mary Worthy 2, Hall 2 and Pickard 2. L Smith led West Kent with 15. E Smith added 5, Whitlock 2 and Taylor 1.
The runner-up West Kent: Lucy Smith; E Smith; H Whitlock; W Taylor; M Jardine; J Campbell; Vessey; Rogers; Westegard; B MacDonald;
The champion Charlottetown Prince Street: B Whitlock; Barbara Wran; Mary Worthy; Hall; Pickard; Sylvia Soper; Helen Cook; Matheson; MacPherson; Rogerson; J MacDougall; Z Skinner; Elaine Murphy; Jane Holt;
1953
In the finals, Charlottetown Prince Street defeated Charlottetown West Kent 27-29; 19-18; 23-20 (2g-1).
In game two, Prince Street prevailed 19-18 as MacPherson scored 6, Rogerson 5, Whitlock 5 and Matheson 3. Lucy Smith led West Kent with 12. Phillips 4 and Campbell 2.
In game three, Prince Street prevailed 23-20 as Barb Wran scored 8, Barbara Whitlock 4, Rodgerson 4 and MacPherson 4 and MacDougall 3. Lucy Smith led West Kent with 18. Campbell added 2.
The runner-up West Kent: Lucy Smith; Campbell; Rogers; Batt; Jardine; MacKinnon; Phillips;
The champion Charlottetown Prince Street: Barbara Wran; Barbara Whitlock; Maida Rogerson; Winnie MacPherson; MacDougall; Matheson; Sherren;
1954
In the quarterfinals, Charlottetown Prince Street defeated West Kent 32-5. West Kent included B Houston, W MacDonald, J Vessey, P Johnston, B Stewart, J Cerry, L Smith and P MacDonald.
In the semis, Charlottetown Prince Street defeated Summerside High 44-8.
In the other semi, Rochford Square defeated Notre Dame Academy 25-15. Notre Dame Academy included K Jay, R Gillis, D Connolly, L Murphy, E MacInnis, M Poer and L MacKinnon.
In the final, Charlottetown Prince Street defeated Rochford Square 29-28 in double overtime.
The championship was separately reported as Charlottetown Prince Street having defeated Rochford Square 18-24; 33-21 (Total: 51-45).
In game two, Prince Street prevailed 33-21 as Winnie MacPherson scored 13, Janet Matheson 8, Beryl Shelfoon 6, Maida Rogerson 4 and Jean MacDougall 2. Theresa Gallant led Rochford Square with 7. Martha Cummiskey added 4, Daphne MacMillan 4, Pearl Stanley 3 and Barbara Ward 3.
The silver medalist Rochford Square: Pearl Stanley; Barbara Ward; Martha Cummiskey; Daphne MacMillan; Betty Gallant; Theresa Gallant; coach George Ward
The champion Charlottetown Prince Street: Maida Rogerson; Jean MacDougall; Winnie MacPherson; Beryl Shelfoon; Janet Matheson; Beryl MacLean; Diane Jenkins; Mary Milligan; Joyce MacCannell; Sandra Cairns; coach Jack Ross; assistant Rollie Lea; manager Allan Bowness
1955
In the annual PEI physical fitness interscholastic tourney, there was one game, with Queen Charlotte defeating Rochford.
Rochford: Martha Commiskey, Betty Gallant, Paul Noona, Justine Basha, Marie Doirin
Queen Charlotte: Mary Milligan, Pauline Johnston, Pat MacDonald, Donna Cudmore, Ginny Vessey, Barbara Stewart, Norma Duvar, Roberta Strang, coach Wayne MacDonald