| YEAR | 1ST-TEAM | 2ND-TEAM |
| 15-16 | Thon Maker – Athlete Inst Prep Eugene Omoruyi – Orangeville Prep Justin Jackson – The Hill Academy Ignas Brazdekis – Orangeville Prep Godwin Boahen – The Hill Academy | Matur Maker – Athlete Inst Prep Nikola Djogo – Athlete Inst Prep Jahvon Blair – Orangeville Prep Stefan Smith – Bill Crothers Ahmed Ali – BTB Prep |
| 16-17 | Howard Washington Jr – Athlete Inst Prep Oshae Brissett – Athlete Inst Prep Stefan Smith – Bill Crothers Ignas Brazdeikis – Orangeville Prep Eleil Nsoseme – TRC Academy | Jahvon Blair – Athlete Inst Prep Junior Farquhar – Orangeville Prep Keshaun Saunders – Orangeville Prep Jaden Bediako – Ridley College Xavier Ochu – Southwest Academy |
| 17-18 | Ignas Brazdeikis – Orangeville Prep Luguentz Dort – Athlete Inst Prep Adong Makuoi – TRC Academy Daniel Sackey – Thornlea SS Prep Antoine Vernon – TRC Academy | Junior Farquhar – Orangeville Prep Rahmir Moore – RISE Prep Luka Sakota – King’s Christian Keshaun Saunders – Orangeville Prep Coleman Stucke – King’s Christian |
| 18-19 | Jaden Bediako – St. Catherines Ridley Rahim Moore – Brantford RISE Prep Kobe Elvis – London Southwest Academy Miguel Tomley – Brantford RISE Prep Luka Sakota – Oakville King’s Christian | Noah Wharton – St. Catherines Ridley Keeshawn Barthelemey – Thornhill Thornlea Tyrese Samuel – Mono Orangeville Matthew-Alexander Mondreiff – Mono Orangeville Tyler Sagl – Hamilton Lincoln Prep |
| 19-20 | Jefferson Koulibaly – Lincoln Prep Matthew Alexander Moncrieffe – Orangeville Prep Kobe Elvis – Bill Crothers S.S. Coleman Stucke – Orangeville Prep Jamal Fuller – Central Tech | Javonte Brown – Thornlea S.S. Caleb Johnson – FHC Prep Dawson John – TRC Academy Elijah Fisher – Crestwood Prep Shemar Rathan-Mayes – Orangeville Prep |
| 20-21 | Season cancelled (covid-19 pandemic) | Season cancelled (covid-19 pandemic) |
| 21-22 | Leonard Miller – Fort Erie Elijah Fischer – Crestwood Prep Jeremy Foumena – Orangeville Prep Armani Mighty – United Scholastic Zaiden Cross – Crestwood Prep | Pierre Mukandila – Niagara Prep Michael Evbagharu – Royal Crown Jaden Clayton – Fort Erie Jefferson Monegro – Orangeville Prep Ose Okojie – United Scholastic 3rd Romad Dean – Crestwood Prep Josh Omojafo – Lincoln Prep Jaden Witter-Watts – Toronto Prep Thierno Sylla – Royal Crown Immanuel Oludele – Ridley College |
| 22-23 | Pool A 1st Michael Evbagharu – Royal Crown Ibrahim Sacko – J. Addison Felix Kossaras – Fort Erie Red Efiosa Oliogu – United Scholastic David Simon – Royal Crown Pool A 2nd Matai Baptiste – Orangeville Sean Blake – Victory Academy Victor Bonsu – Crestwood Prep Jahari Williamson – Royal Crown Jalik Dunkley Distant – Orangeville | Pool B 1st Spencer Ahrens – PEDSDMD Elite Babatunde Durodola – Inspire Acad. Andrew Urosevic – Ridley Kaden Stuckey – Ridley Bashir Ngala – Fort Erie Int’l Pool B 2nd Andrew Loyuk – Kennedy Prep Waqo Tessema – Fort Erie Int’l Yashar Greaves Saadat – Kennedy Prep Timothy Eze – Bill Crothers Nate Bureau – Fort Erie Int’l |
| 23-24 | Ishan Sharma – Fort Erie Red Mariel Akuentola – Fort Eric Red Sean Blake – Royal Crown Timothy Eze – Bill Crothers Justus Haseley – Royal Crown | |