| ALL-CONFERENCE 1ST | 2ND | |
| 67-68 | ||
| 68-69 | ||
| 69-70 | ||
| 70-71 | ||
| 71-72 | ||
| 72-73 | ||
| 73-74 | ||
| 74-75 | ||
| 75-76 | ||
| 76-77 | Donny Donovan – Cape Breton | |
| 77-78 | ||
| 78-79 | ||
| 79-80 | ||
| 80-81 | ||
| 81-82 | ||
| 82-83 | ||
| 83-84 | Tim Kendrick – Nova Scotia Teachers | |
| 84-85 | Tim Kendrick – Nova Scotia Teachers Steve Gallant – UNB-Saint John | |
| 85-86 | David MacKinnon – Cape Breton Vince MacCormack – TUNS Steven Spurr – TUNS | |
| 86-87 | Kevin Newcombe – Mount St. Vincent Kent MacLeod – Nova Scotia Teachers Kelly Rambeau – Nova Scotia Teachers | Kevin Nettle – Mount St. Vincent |
| 87-88 | ||
| 88-89 | Jon Hunt – Nova Scotia Teachers | |
| 89-90 | Jesse Diepenveen – Mount St. Vincent Mark Forward – Mount St. Vincent Paul Forward – Mount St. Vincent Cyril Veinot – Nova Scotia Teachers | |
| 90-91 | Anthony Ross – Mount St. Vincent Mark Forward – Mount St. Vincent | |
| 91-92 | Tony Ross – Mt. St. Vincent Mark Forward – Mt. St. Vincent Andrew McNeil – Mt. St. Vincent | |
| 92-93 | ||
| 93-94 | ||
| 94-95 | Mark Clarke – Mt. St. Vincent Todd Hirtle – Mt. St. Vincent Kevin Hayden – Nova Scotia Teachers Cory Taylor – Nova Scotia Teachers Scott Mazzerole – N.S.A.C. | Ryan Dickinson – St. Thomas Josh Symonds – St. Thomas Levant Ersoy – Technical U of NS Mike Roger – King’s Scott Rawding – Mount Allison |
| 95-96 | Mark Clarke – Mount Saint Vincent Alex Kidney – UNB-Saint John Corey Taylor – Nova Scotia Teachers Kevin Hayden – Nova Scotia Teachers Scott Mazerolle – NSAC | Wayne Hinds – UNB-Saint John Scott Rawding – Mount Allison Mike Rogers – King’s Malik Adams – Mount St. Vincent Ryan Dickinson – St. Thomas |
| 96-97 | Mark Clarke – Mount St. Vincent Todd Hirtle – Mount St. Vincent Mike Fisher – NSAC Rob Lordon – King’s David Klein – Mount Allison | Seth Kingsbury – NSAC David Reynolds – King’s Levant Ersoy – TUNS Colin Wetmore – St. Thomas Stefan Hoddinott – Mount Allison |
| 97-98 | Seth Kingsbury – NSAC Robbie McGregor – NSAC Alvin Bell – UNB-Saint John Mike Bonnar – St. Thomas Craig Simpson – Mount St. Vincent | Fred Connors – St. Thomas Robert Ryan – Mount Allison Mike Rogers – Dal Tech Jason Brunt – Mount St. Vincent Mike Fisher – Dal Tech |
| 98-99 | Alvin Bell – UNB-Saint John Peter Turnbull – Mount St. Vincent Mike Roger – Dalhousie Tech Mike McLeod – Mt. Allison Rob McGregor – Nova Scotia Agricultural | Mike Bonnar – St. Thomas Mike Fisher – Dalhousie Tech Fred Connors – St. Thomas Josh Kingsbury – Nova Scotia Agricultural Steve LeBlanc – UNB-Saint John |
| 99-00 | Mike McLeod – Mt. Allison Robbie McGregor – NSAC Josh Kingsbury – NSAC Shane Butland – St. Thomas Peter Turnbull – Mount Saint Vincent | Steve Sykes – Mount Allison Ian MacLellan – Mount Allison Mike McLeod – Mount Allision Jayson Taker – Mount Saint Vincent Steve LeBlanc – UNB-Saint John |
| 00-01 | Mike Bonnar – St. Thomas Mike McLeod – Mt. Allison Dan Dunford – Nova Scotia Agricultural Jayson Taker – Mount Allison Ian MacRae – Mount Allison | Barry Brennan – St. Thomas Sean Breen – UNB- Saint John Sam Assembe – UNB-Saint John Greg Richards – Mount Allison Dennis Humphreys – King’s |
| 01-02 | Kevin Hobbs – U of King’s College Alan Williams – Mount Saint Vincent David Robson – St. Thomas Dennis Ashe – U of King’s College Dylan Meisner – Mount St. Vincent | Zac McIsaac – Mount Allison Shaun Alie – Mount Allison Damintota Beyentin – Moncton Sam Assembe – UNB-Saint John Barry Brennan – St. Thomas |
| 02-03 | David Robson – St. Thomas Nathan Bokma – NSAC Dennis Ashe – King’s Scott Fraser – St. Thomas Robert Turnbull – Mount St. Vincent | Brendan McCarville – Mount Allison Zac McIsaac – Mount Allison Courtney Dabney – Mount St. Vincent Steve Lawrence – St. Thomas Joe Dow – New Brunswick-Saint John |
| 03-04 | David Robson – St. Thomas Barry Bryan – Mount Saint Vincent Chris de Wolfe – Mount Saint Vincent Zac McIsaac – Mount Allison Matt Jones – King’s | Steve Lawrence – St. Thomas Andrew Robson – St. Thomas Joe Dow – New Brunswick-Saint John Billy McNutt – Nova Scotia Agricultural Robert Despres – Moncton |
| 04-05 | Tim Adams – King’s Matt Jones – King’s Aaron Carpenter – King’s Shawn Clarke – Mount Saint Vincent Chris DeWolfe – Mount Saint Vincent | Jeremy McLean – UNB-Saint John Scott Hachey – UNB-Saint John Cedrick Kabongo – Moncton Doyle Anthony – Mount St. Vincent Jay Walsh – St. Thomas |
| 05-06 | Brendan Arnold – Mt. St. Vincent Tim Adams – King’s Chad Smith – King’s Shawn Clarke – Mount Saint Vincent | Matt Jones – King’s Aaron Carpenter – King’s |
| 06-07 | Damian Gay – Mt. St. Vincent Doyle Anthony – Mount Allison Aaron Carpenter – King’s Billy McNutt – Nova Scotia Agricultural Dan Budd – St. Thomas | Tim McAleenan – Mt. Allison Brendon Arnold – Mt. St. Vincent Steve Morris – Mt. St. Vincent Allison MacKay – St. Thomas Colin Johnson – UNB-Saint John |
| 07-08 | Damian Gay – Mount St. Vincent Brendan Arnold – Mount St. Vincent Jason Carlson – Mount St. Vincent Doyle Anthony – Mount Allison Aaron Carpenter – King’s | Chris Leger – Atlantic Baptist Scott Black – Atlantic Baptist Steve Morris – Mt. St. Vincent Kent Matheson – Mount Allison Clifton Riley – King’s |
| 08-09 | Jason Carlson – Mount Saint Vincent Ibrahaim Toulany – Mount Saint Vincent Adam Jewkes – Mount Saint Vincent Clint Bateman – Atlantic Baptist Scott Hachey – New Brunswick-Saint John | Kent Matheson – Mount Allison Josh Graham – Mount Allison Jacob Ayangma – Holland Steve Morris – Mount St. Vincent Matt Robertson – St. Thomas |
| 09-10 | Graham Scott – New Brunswick-Saint John Steve Morris – Mount St. Vincent Matt Fowler – Holland Josh Graham –Mt. Allison Adam Jewkes – Mount St. Vincent | Carl Wickstrom – Mount St. Vincent Steve Hardy – Holland Karl Frederick – Crandall Ryan MacPherson – St. Thomas J.D. Howlett – University of King’s College |
| 10-11 | Donathan Moss – Holland J.D. Howlett – King’s Sean Boulay – Mount St. Vincent Todd Williams – Mount St. Vincent Luke Reynolds – Mount St. Vincent | Anthony Zinn – Mount St. Vincent Matt Robertson – Crandall Ben Chisholm – Mt. Allison Brad LeBritton – St. Thomas Alex MacLeod – Holland |
| 11-12 | Leo Morris – Holland Eamon Morrissey – King’s Luke Reynolds – Mount St. Vincent J.D. Howlett – King’s Kenneth Reardon – Mount St. Vincent | Nathan Mazurkiewicz – St. Thomas Joe Kendrick – Crandall Brandon Malally – Mount Allison Taylor Norum – Crandall Todd Williams – Mount St. Vincent |
| 12-13 | Nathan Mazurkiewicz – St. Thomas Ben Chisholm – Mount Allison Chase Bowden – Holland Alvin Parker – Holland Ken Reardon – Mount Saint Vincent | Jason Daniels – St. Thomas Kemoy Shaw – Crandall Nathaniel Fells – Crandall Leo Morris – Holland Thomas Watson – King’s |
| 13-14 | Osman Barrie – Crandall Chase Bowden – Holland Arnar Bjornsson – Mount St. Vincent Nathan Mazurkiewicz – St. Thomas Alvin Parker – Holland | Nathaniel Fells – Crandall Corey Hollett – Mount St. Vincent Achuil Lual – Crandall Orlando Palmer – Holland Thomas Watson – King’s |
| 14-15 | William Barber – St. Thomas Chase Bowden – Holland Kaleefah Henry – Mount Allison Thomarcus Nix – Crandall D.J. Wright – Holland | Akil Charles – Crandall Ryan Harnett – University of King’s College Corey Hollett – Mount St. Vincent Eamon Morrissy – Holland Orlando Palmer – Holland |
| 15-16 | Bradley Fuller – Mount Allison Trevone Grant – Holland Ryan Harnett – University of King’s College Thomarcus Nix – Crandall Roosevelt Whyley – Holland | Travis Adams – Holland Alex Chisholm – Mount Allison Emad Khalek – Mount St. Vincent Derek Norris – Mount St. Vincent Thomas Watson – University of King’s College |
| 16-17 | Thomarcus Nix – Crandall Thomas LaGaillis – Mount Allison Roosevelt Whyley – Holland Trenity Burdine – Holland | Brandon Fields – Crandall Brad Fuller – Mount Allison |
| 17-18 | Thomas LeGallais – Mt. Allison Brandon Fields – Crandall Roosevelt Whyley – Holland Marcus Dawkins – Holland Jace Colley – Holland | Hassan Maidal – Crandall Ashton Slawter – Mount St. Vincent Brad Sanford – Mt. Allison Hunter Gray – New Brunswick-Saint John Robin Grouse – Dalhousie Agricultural |
| 18-19 | Roosevelt Whyley – Holland College Jace Colley – Holland College Kendall Brown – Crandall University Liam Mitchell – Mount St. Vincent University Aram Currie – Mount Allison University | Keegan Gray – UNBSJ Jordan Holness – Holland College Ben West – University of King’s College Campbell Colpitts – University of King’s College Brody Blakney – Mount St. Vincent University |
| 19-20 | Brody Blakney – Mount St. Vincent Jordan Holness – Holland Geoffrey Lavoie – St. Thomas Sam Pierson – Mt. Allison Adrian Thompson- Holland | Almin Dervisevic – St. Thomas Colby Lawrence – Crandall Daniel Maxwell – Crandall Liam Mitchell – Mount St. Vincent Jayden Nordin – King’s |
| 20-21 | None selected (covid-19 pandemic) | None selected (covid-19 pandemic) |
| 21-22 | Brett Curtis – Crandall University Jordan Holness – Holland College Gayo Isaya – St. Thomas University Jayden Nordin – University of King’s College Sam Pierson – Mount Allison University | Bryce Corless – Holland College Almin Dervisevic – St. Thomas University Jasha’juan Downey – Holland College Devon Glen – Crandall University Geoffrey Lavoie – St. Thomas University |
| 22-23 | Devon Glenn – Crandall Geoffrey Lavoie – St. Thomas Noah McCarthy – Mount Allison Jalen Menzies – Holland Will Spalding – Mount Saint Vincent | James French – Crandall Gayo Isaya – St. Thomas Logan Rempel – Holland Tario Sands – Mount St. Vincent Kyree Thompson – Holland |
| 23-24 | Bryce Corless – Holland Tim Ellison – Mount Allison Geoffrey Lavoie – St. Thomas Noah McCarthy – St. Thomas Chase Tynes – Mt. St. Vincent | Jack Fury-Miller – UNB-Saint John Marc Hofer – Crandall Jaydan Smith – Mt. St. Vincent Jaxon Smith – Mt. St. Vincent Ethan Szemerda – UNB-Saint John |
| ALL-TOURNEY | ||
| 73-74 | *Ricky Nixon – UNB-Saint John | |
| 92-93 | ||
| 93-94 | ||
| 94-95 | ||
| 95-96 | ||
| 96-97 | ||
| 97-98 | ||
| 98-99 | ||
| 99-00 | ||
| 00-01 | ||
| 01-02 | ||
| 02-03 | ||
| 03-04 | ||
| 04-05 | Shawn Clarke – Mount Saint Vincent Chris DeWolfe – Mount Saint Vincent Tim Adams – King’s Aaron Carpenter – King’s Scott Hachey – UNBSJ Matt Jones – Kings | |
| 05-06 | ||
| 06-07 | ||
| 07-08 | ||
| 08-09 | ||
| 09-10 | ||
| 10-11 | ||
| 11-12 | None selected | |