| ALL-CONFERENCE 1ST | 2ND | |
| 00-01 | ||
| 01-02 | ||
| 02-03 | Dan Hostrup – Providence Darcy Hanchuk – Providence | Graham Bodnar – Providence Randy Foss – Western Christian |
| 03-04 | ||
| 04-05 | ||
| 05-06 | ||
| 06-07 | ||
| 07-08 | ||
| 08-09 | Josh Olaes – Red River Lawrence Miclash – Canadian Mennonite Jonar Huertas – Red River Anthony Dahl – Oak Hills Christian Kurtis Sansregret – Red River Nick Miller – Canadian Mennonite | |
| 09-10 | Josh Olaes – Red River Josh Stolar – Red River Paul Muns – Canadian Mennonite Kevin Quirante – Canadian Mennonite Joel Coursey – Providence Chris Funk – Providence | |
| 10-11 | Jon Picicci – University of Winnipeg Given Isaac – University of Winnipeg Lexy Blacksmith – University of Winnipeg Cory Neufeld – Red River College Josh Olaes – Red River College Wyatt Anders – Canadian Mennonite | |
| 11-12 | Wyatt Anders – Canadian Mennonite University Lexy Blacksmith – University of Winnipeg Jason Malcolm – Red River College Jon Piccici – U of Winnipeg College Mike Hebert – Red River College Jacob Miller – Canadian Mennonite | |
| 12-13 | *Mike Hebert – Red River Stephen Jones – Canadian Mennonite Mike Villanueva – U of Winnipeg College Daman Morissette – Red River Kyle Queijo – Red River Johnathan Thompson – Providence UC | |
| 13-14 | *Given Isaac, University of Winnipeg College *Keenan Benarroch – University of Winnipeg College Johnathan Thompson – Providence University College Sam Kinsley – Canadian Mennonite University Lloyd Hildebrand – Red River College Vince Munoz – Red River College Evan Walker – Red River College | |
| 14-15 | *Lloyd Hildebrand – Red River College Stephen Ralko – University of Winnipeg College Taylor Brown – Red River College Romeo KC – Providence University College Rigueson Desorvil – Providence University College Eric Johnson – Providence University College | |
| 15-16 | Romeo KC – Providence University College Jon Hayter – Canadian Mennonite University Jacob Penner – Canadian Mennonite University Daniel Dekleva – Providence University College Chris Bartolay – University of Winnipeg College Taylor Brow – Red River | |
| 16-17 | Romeo KC – Providence University College Jon Wilner – Red River Sam Kinsley – Canadian Mennonite Richard Rodgers – Providence University College Ridel Ebero – Canadian Mennonite | |
| 17-18 | Chris Demauleon-Martolay – Red River Jaden Harms – Canadian Mennonite Jordan Lawson – Providence Kendall Perpall – Providence Steve Williamson – Red River | Honourable Mention Chris Dick – Providence Nick Kasmik – Canadian Mennonite Mark Ridd – Red River Kneil Sullera – Canadian Mennonite |
| 18-19 | ||
| 19-20 | ||
| 20-21 | Season cancelled (covid pandemic) | |
| 21-22 | None selected (according to MCAC officials) | |
| 22-23 | Daniel Cameron – Canadian Mennonite Ezra Leano – Canadian Mennonite Joshua Armstrong – Providence UC Riley Paul – Providence UC Daniel Conway – Saint-Boniface |
| 23-24 | Emmanuel Oleko – Providence Daniel Cameron – Canadian Mennonite Isaiah Cole – Canadian Mennonite Braeden Fernandez – Canadian Mennonite Riley Paul – Providence | HM Cabrel St. Vincent – Saint Boniface |