| YEAR | 1ST-TEAM | 2ND-TEAM |
| 16-17 | Danilo Djuricic – St. Mike’s Cordell Veira – Toronto Basketball Academy Jashon Henry – Wilcox Notre Dame Keenan Dowell – B.C. Christian Steven Rwahwire – Toronto Central Tech | Jalen Warren – London Basketball Academy David Penney – London Basketball Academy Lual Akot – Top Flight Academy Will Spaulding – Rothesay-Netherwood A.J. Lawson – GTA Prep |
| 17-18 | Jashon Henry – Wilcox Notre Dame Raheim Sullivan – Toronto Central Tech A.J. Lawson – Mississauga GTA Prep Franco Miller – North York Crestwood | Adefolarin Adetogun – Wilcox Notre Dame David Muila – Top Flight Academy Luol Akot – Top Flight Academy Denzel Cummins – London Basketball Academy Sheyheim Malcolm – Rothesay Netherwood |
| 18-19 | Jahcobi Neath – Toronto Crestwood Adefolarin Adetogun – Calgary Edge Kellen Tynes – Rothesay Netherwood Dragan Stajic – Canada Top Flight Academy Tesloch Luk – Canada Top Flight Academy | Cole Newkirk – Saskatoon Basketball Academy Amir Gholizadeh – Toronto Basketball Academy Akoi Yuot – Halifax Prep Jordan Persad – Oakville Basketball Prep Shyheim Malcolm – Rothesay Netherwood |
| 19-20 | Kellen Tynes – Rotheway Netherwood Jashua’jaun Downey – Toronto Basketball Academy Jordan Persaud – Oakville Basketball Prep Atiki Ally Atiki – London Basketball Academy Samuel Alamutu – Rothesay Netherwood | Zaiden Cross – Bill Crothers SS Louth Koulibay – Canada Top Flight Enoch Kalambay – Canada Top Flight Aboucar Traore – Dynasty Sports Institute Thow Biel – Calgary Edge |
| 20-21 | None selected (cancelled, covid-19 pandemic) | None selected (cancelled, covid-19 pandemic) |