| YEAR | ALL-TOURNEY/ALL-LEAGUE |
| 49-50 | ——————— |
| 50-51 | |
| 51-52 | |
| 52-53 | |
| 53-54 | |
| 54-55 | |
| 55-56 | |
| 56-57 | |
| 57-58 | |
| 58-59 | |
| 59-60 | |
| 60-61 | |
| 61-62 | |
| 62-63 | |
| 63-64 | |
| 64-65 | |
| 65-66 | |
| 66-67 | |
| 67-68 | |
| 68-69 | |
| 69-70 | |
| 70-71 | |
| 71-72 | |
| 72-73 | |
| 73-74 | |
| 74-75 | |
| 75-76 | |
| 76-77 | |
| 77-78 | *Doreen Waugh – Three Oaks Anna Pendergast – Kensington Karen Rowell – Morell Kathy Chandler – Colonel Gray Virginia Morris – Three Oaks |
| 78-79 | |
| 79-80 | *Dana Clow – Kensington Michelle Trainer – Colonel Gray Paula Ripley – Kensington Nanette Elsinga – Kensington Susan Grady – Three Oaks Nancy Bernard – Three Oaks |
| 80-81 | *Lori Kane – Colonel Gray Dora Inman – Colonel Gray Dawna Noonan – Colonel Gray Joanne Jackson – Three Oaks Carol MacEwan – Three Oaks Sandra Clark – Kensington |
| 81-82 | |
| 82-83 | *Peggy MacLean – Morell Donna Gaudet – Three Oaks Susie Clow – Three Oaks Michelle Ives – Rural Janet Simmons – Kensington Janet Nicholls – Morell |
| 83-84 | *Nadine Inman – Three Oaks Green Tracey Bowie – Rural Sharon Carr – Three Oaks Green Shawna Bernard – Kensington Sandra Sheefington – Rural Susan Knickle – Colonel Gray |
| 84-85 | *Susan Coles – Three Oaks Lisa Allain – Three Oaks Nadine Enman – Three Oaks Susan Knickle – Colonel Gray Cathy Mutter – Bluefield Shawna Bernard – Kensington |
| 85-86 | *Elaine Partridge – Colonel Gray Tara Bowness – Kensington Angela Sanderson – Bluefield Lynn Heaney – Kensington Stephanie Knickle – Colonel Gray Donna Townsend – Colonel Gray |
| 86-87 | *Marjorie Cameron – Three Oaks Mary Cameron – Three Oaks Tara Bowness – Kensington Cathy Lawlor – Rural Kelly Copeland – Three Oaks Gail Morell – Colonel Gray |
| 87-88 | *Kathy Quinn – Rural Lori Knickle – Gray Tara Bowness – Kensington Kelly Copeland – Three Oaks Leanne Weeks – Kensington Sherry Flynn – Gray |
| 88-89 | *Randi Lang – Julie Smith – Colonel Gray Krista Ling – Jennifer Picketts – Elaine Crossman – Kendra Gunn – |
| 89-90 | *Julie Smith – Colonel Gray Vanessa MacLean – Colonel Gray Rachel Ross – Rural Shelleigh Simmons – Kensington Michelle Compton – Three Oaks Tracey Pineau – Colonel Gray |
| 90-91 | *Kathy Ford – Rural Candace Ling – Rural Kelly Lund – Rural Lara Vos – Colonel Gray Lindsay Linkletter – Colonel Gray Karen Cameron – Three Oaks 2nd Carolyn Deighan – Three Oaks Tracey Champion – Kensington Jody Dickson – Colonel Gray Celeste Coles – Kensington Jennifer Sirois – Rural |
| 91-92 | *Jennifer Sirois – Rural Jennifer Johnston – Montague Lana McMurrer – Rural Tara Nogler – Colonel Gray Julie Gallant – Three Oaks Heidi Moase – Three Oaks |
| 92-93 | *Lisa Resnitzky – Colonel Gray Kara Saunders – Colonel Gray Karen Cameron – Three Oaks Heidi Moyse – Three Oaks Nadine Sinclair – Kensington Jamie MacEachern – Rural |
| 93-94 | *Jennifer Johnston – Colonel Gray Karen Vos – Colonel Gray Jamie Montgomery – Kensington Mariska Termeer – Morell Lisa Resnitzky – Colonel Gray Trish Waugh – Three Oaks |
| 94-95 | *Karen Vos – Colonel Gray Bethany Lund – Rural Kate Myron – Bluefield Janet Thomas – Colonel Gray Kelly Larkin – Colonel Gray Margo Olscamp – Three Oaks |
| 95-96 | *Krista Connolly – Colonel Gray-AA Melanie Hansen – Westisle Bethany Lund – Rural-AA Sara Ford – Westisle Jaclyn Coady – Bluefield Kate Ellis – Colonel Gray-AA |
| 96-97 | *Kate Ellis – Colonel Gray-AA Joslin Cheverie – Colonel Gray-AA Marlo McGuigan – Colonel Gray-AA Caroline Ellis – Colonel Gray-AA Laura Diamond – Rural-AA Kate Myron – Bluefield Heidi LeClair – Westisle |
| 97-98 | *Carrie Houston – Colonel Gray Corinne Larkin – Colonel Gray Jane Vessey – Colonel Gray Laura Diamond – Rural-AA Sarah Adams – Rural-A Lindsay Bellefontaine – Kensington |
| 98-99 | *Tamara MacDougall – Colonel Gray-AA Angela Hansen – Westisle-AA Nicole Kelly – Three Oaks-AA Rebecca Campbell – Rural-AA Marie Gaudet – Rural-AA Katherine Walters – Colonel GrayAA |
| 99-00 | *Jessica Davidson – Rural Laura MacPherson – Bluefield Aimee Cameron – Bluefield Tamara McDougall – Colonel Gray Katherine Walters – Colonel Gray Lindsay Coade – Rural |
| 00-01 | *Katherine Walters – Colonel Gray Lindsay Coade – Rural Megan MacMillan – Colonel Gray Elizabeth MacPhail – Colonel Gray Laura MacPherson – Hampshire Bluefield Krista Turtle – Three Oaks |
| 01-02 | *Elizabeth MacPhail – Colonel Gray Victoria Walker – Three Oaks Kyla Dewar – Three Oaks M.C. Connolly – Colonel Gray Amanda Hood – Rural Vanessa Foster – Rural |
| 02-03 | *M.C. Connolly – Colonel Gray Cassie Goodwin – Colonel Gray Victoria Walker – Three Oaks Megan MacDonald – Three Oaks Megan Wilson – Rural Jill Youland – Hampshire Bluefield |
| 03-04 | *Katrina Clow – Kensington April Fisher – Souris Mary MacKinnon – Three Oaks Paula MacDonald – Montague Rebecca Gallant – Kensington Megan Sheridan – Kensington |
| 04-05 | *Geena Shea – Westisle Paula Macdonald – Montague-1 Cailin Crosby – Kensington Tara Bernard – Westisle Tegan Boertien – Souris April Fisher – Souris |
| 05-06 | *Taylor Fitzgerald – Colonel Gray-2 Kelly MacDonald – Montague Melissa MacDonald – Morell Ashton Gallant – Westisle Emaliee Wakelyn – Colonel Gray-2 Amanda Wells – Westisle |
| 06-07 | *Meaghan McQuaid – Souris Samara Meade – Morell Emilee Wakelin – Col Gray Jillian MacKenzie – Hampshire Bluefield Julie Deveau – Souris Alicia Rose – Col Gray |
| 07-08 | *Ashton Gallant – Elmsdale Westisle Alana Murphy – Montague Lisa Mills – Colonel Gray-2 Kelcy McNally – Morell Kayla McNally – Morell Santana Wedge – Elmsdale Westisle |
| 08-09 | *Kayla McNally – Morell Tessa Stammberger – Kensington Katelyn Powers – Montague Kassandra Horne – Elmsdale Westisle Jessica Smith – Elmsdale Westisle Kelcy McNally – Morell |
| 09-10 | *Kayla McNally – Morell Laura Younker – Colonel Gray Katelyn Powers – Montague Nicole Kelly – Morell Kelcy McNally – Morell Jane McLaughlin – Souris |
| 10-11 | *Logan MacAuley – Three Oaks-2 Laura Younker – Colonel Gray Brianna Arsenault – Three Oaks-2 Tasha MacKinnon – Three Oaks-2 Jenna Gallant – Westisle Emily Malone – Westisle |
| 11-12 | *Amy Dawson – Bluefield Ashley Simmons – Three Oaks Ellen Arsenault – Three Oaks Madelyn Stewart – Souris Laura Younger – Colonel Gray Sydney Foy – Bluefield |
| 12-13 | *Abbey Kinch – Colonel Gray-2 Sydney Moore – Souris Emma MacLean – Kensington Jordan Havenga – Bluefield Amy Dawson – Bluefield Dana Trainor – Colonel Gray-2 |
| 13-14 | *Julia Stark – Colonel Gray-2 Shanley Saunders – Montague Jayne Robertson – Souris Maggie Fraser – Westisle Danielle Younker – Colonel Gray Breanne Lewis – Westisle |
| 14-15 | *Hannah Harrington – Kensington Cassidy Champion – Kensington Erin MacKinnon – Three Oaks-2 Taran Price – Three Oaks-2 Lexi Getson – Westisle Danielle Younker –Charlottetown Colonel Gray-2 |
| 15-16 | *Cassidy Champion – Kensington Christina Lourenso – Charlottetown Rural Vanessa Rennie – Westisle Madison MacKinnon – Westisle Meghan Stewart – Souris Kelsey MacLean – Kensington |
| 16-17 | *Alexa Rancourt – Grace Christian Jasmine Laybolt – Souris Haley Cole – Bluefield Abby MacDonald – Bluefield Zoe Good – Grace Christian Danielle McGonnell – Grace Christian |
| 17-18 | *Makayla Vos – Bluefield-1 Abby Hameline – Montague Alexa Rancourt – Grace Christian Ellen Cole – Kensington Haley Cole – Bluefield-1 Hope Muttart – Bluefield-1 League 1st Haley Cole – Bluefield Brianna Dodd – Montague Abby Hamelin – Montague Hillary MacLean – Kensington Alexa Rancourt – Grace Christian 2nd Ellen Cole – Kensington Lox MacMillan – Montague Danielle McGonnell – Grace Christian Hope Muttart – Bluefield Makayla Vos – Bluefield |
| 18-19 | *Morgan Jardine – Montague Hillary Murray – Kensington Molly Birtwhistle – Rural-2 Hannah McGonnell – Grace Christian Alexa Rancourt – Grace Christian Allison Vandaele – Montague League 1st Molly Birtwhistle – Rural-2 Callie Champion – Kensington Ellen Cole – Kensington Abby Hameline – Montague Kate MacIntosh – Rural-2 League 2nd Casey Currie – Rural-2 Morgan Jardine – Montague Hannah McGonnell – Grace Christian Erin Morris – Montague Ellen Murphy – Kensington Alexa Rancourt – Grace Christian Allison Vandaele – Montague |
| 19-20 | *Emma Stanley – Rural-2 Desiree LaPierre – Three Oaks-2 Anna Lucaisse – Bluefield-2 Chloe MacDonald – Rural-2 Olivia MacLellan – Rural-2 Heidi Thibodeau – Westisle-1 League 1st Chloe MacDonald – Rural-2 Eve Murphy – Bluefield-2 Emma Stanley – Rural-2 Kaylee Stewart – Morell Heidi Thibideau – Westisle-1 2nd Jill Arsenault – Three Oaks-2 Jaiden Encina – Rural-2 Desiree LaPierre – Three Oaks-2 Carmen Minnis – Morell Megan Moase – Three Oaks-2 |
| 20-21 | None selected (cancelled, covid-19 pandemic) |
| 21-22 | *Kathleen Ryan – Montague Jill Harper – Westisle Victoria Zakem – Colonel Gray Brooke Walsh – Rural Neely Johnston – Rural Lila Johnston – Montague |
| 22-23 | *Katelyn Brothers – Montague Bella VanColen – Montague Elsie Taweel – Bluefield-2 Olivia Pot – Bluefield-2 Molly MacNeill – Rural-2 Grace Bulger – Rural-2 Ashley Hardy – Westisle-1 Ava Tweedy – Gray-2 Jocelyn Rayner – Three Oaks-2 |
| 23-24 | Ashley Hardy – Westisle Addison Langley – Bluefield-2 Karly LeClair – Westisle Iyla Kilbride – Three Oaks-2 Thea Knickle – Colonel Gray-2 Lauren MacCallum – Charlottetown Rural-2 Josie MacLean – Bluefield-2 Molly MacNeil – Charlottetown Rural-2 Andi-Lee Reardon – Bluefield-2 Ava Tweedy – Colonel Gray-2 |