YEAR | CHAMPION | COACH | FINAL | RUNNER-UP |
| 03-04 | Charlottetown Rural | Dave MacNeill/ Brian Chambers | 37-36 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray |
| 04-05 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray | Chris Annett | 56-48 | Summerside Three Oaks |
| 05-06 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray | Chris Annett | 58-44 | Summerside Three Oaks |
| 06-07 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray | Chris Annett | 79-42 | Summerside Three Oaks |
| 07-08 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray | Chris Annett | 70-56 | Summerside Three Oaks |
| 08-09 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray | Chris Annett | 66-52 | Summerside Three Oaks |
| 09-10 | Summerside Three Oaks | David Voye | 71-58 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray |
| 10-11 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray | Chris Annett | 56-51 | Charlottetown Rural |
| 11-12 | Summerside Three Oaks | James Voye | 61-48 | Charlottetown Rural |
| 12-13 | Summerside Three Oaks | James Voye | 49-43 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray |
| 13-14 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray-1 | Chris Annett | 77-50 | Summerside Three Oaks |
| 14-15 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray-1 | Chris Annett | 82-29 | Summerside Three Oaks |
| 15-16 | Charlottetown Rural-1 | Andrew Clark | 49-46 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray-1 |
| 16-17 | Charlottetown Rural-1 | Jason MacDonald | 60-50 | Summerside Three Oaks-1 |
| 17-18 | Charlottetown Rural-1 | Peter Lawlor | 82-35 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray-1 |
| 18-19 | Charlottetown Rural-1 | Peter Lawlor | 61-39 | Summerside Three Oaks-1 |
| 19-20 | Charlottetown Rural-1 | Peter Lawlor | 83-52 | Summerside Three Oaks-1 |
| 20-21 | Charlottetown Rural-1 | Peter Lawlor | 76-50 | Summerside Three Oaks-1 |
| 21-22 | Charlottetown Rural-1 | Peter Lawlor | 75-36 | Summerside Three Oaks-1 |
| 22-23 | Charlottetown Rural-1 | 77-43 | Summerside Three Oaks-1 | |
| 23-24 | Charlottetown Rural-1 | Nicole Davies | 68-50 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray-1 |
| 24-25 | Charlottetown Rural-1 | Nicole Davies | 61-55 | Charlottetown Colonel Gray-1 |