| YEAR | ALL-TOURNEY/ALL-LEAGUE (*denotes MVP) |
| 57-58 | ——————– |
| 58-59 | |
| 59-60 | |
| 60-61 | |
| 61-62 | |
| 62-63 | |
| 63-64 | |
| 64-65 | |
| 65-66 | |
| 66-67 | |
| 67-68 | |
| 68-69 | |
| 69-70 | |
| 70-71 | |
| 71-72 | |
| 72-73 | |
| 73-74 | |
| 74-75 | |
| 75-76 | |
| 76-77 | |
| 77-78 | *Dave Gallant – Colonel Gray Jamie McSwain – Colonel Gray Dave MacEachern – Summerside Three Oaks Steve Cox – Summerside Three Oaks Dave Montgomery – Kensington |
| 78-79 | *Dave Gallant – Colonel Gray |
| 79-80 | *Dave Gallant – Colonel Gray Stephen Cox – Three Oaks Kevin Murphy – Three Oaks Dale MacIsaac – Rural Jim Moore – Colonel Gray Robert Rankin – Colonel Gray |
| 80-81 | *Grant Green – Three Oaks Andy DesRoches – Three Oaks James Quinn – Three Oaks Kent Woodside – Kensington Dale Boswall – Rural David MacIssac – Colonel Gray |
| 81-82 | |
| 82-83 | *Stephen Marchbank – Three Oaks Bobby Burns – Three Oaks Kevin Campbell – Bluefield Forrest Spencer – Charlottetown Rural Brent MacQuaid – Bluefield Don MacKenzie – Colonel Gray |
| 83-84 | *Ronald Deighan – Three Oaks Green Kevin Landry – Three Oaks Green David Jones – Rural Don Chisholm – Three Oaks Green Paul Cameron – Three Oaks Gold Travis Murphy – Montague |
| 84-85 | *Don Chisholm – Three Oaks Gord Matheson – Colonel Gray Brett Wood – Rural Grant Williams – Three Oaks Mark Jones – Westisle Ron Deighan – Three Oaks |
| 85-86 | *Brett Wood – Rural Gordon Matheson – Colonel Gray Alan Vincent – Westisle Adrian Hamilton-Irving – Three Oaks Mark Hatcher – Three Oaks Ricky Younker – Rural |
| 86-87 | *Larry Gallant – Three Oaks Patrick Power – Bluefield Alan Vincent – Westisle Mark Cameron – Three Oaks Jeff Bechervaise – Rural Dean Thibideau – Three Oaks |
| 87-88 | *Dean Thibodeau – Three Oaks Sandy Bathia – Colonel Gray Greg Potten – Montague Mike Collins – Rural Darren Lawless – Three Oaks Mark Cameron – Three Oaks |
| 88-89 | *Jeff McEntee – Colonel Gray James Johnson – Colonel Gray David Simmons – Montague Peter Lawlor – Rural Dale MacDougall – Three Oaks Peter MacKinnon – Rural |
| 89-90 | *Jason Kielly – Rural Mark Corrigan – Rural Mark Mullaly – Rural James Johnson – Colonel Gray Jason MacIssac – Bluefield Forrest Lilly – Three Oaks |
| 90-91 | *Peter Lawlor – Rural *Jason MacDonald – Rural Jason Kielly – Rural David Simmons – Montague Ryan Hickey – Three Oaks Jamie MacDonald – Colonel Gray 2nd Mark Corrigan – Rural Jamie Jones – Colonel Gray Bill Keaveany – Montague Jason Gallant – Three Oaks Fred Wendt – Colonel Gray |
| 91-92 | *Craig Knickle – Colonel Gray Jamie MacDonald – Colonel Gray Troy MacCallum – Rural Chris Huggan – Rural Peter Richard – Three Oaks Wayne Borden – Kensington |
| 92-93 | *Pete Richard – Three Oaks Chris Diamond – Rural Doug Newson – Rural Jamie Jeffery – Three Oaks Jay Nogler – Colonel Gray Jamie Heaney – Kensington |
| 93-94 | *J.D. Johnston – Three Oaks Dave Mullally – Rural Scott Morrison – Morell Steve Lawlor – Rural Randy Sheen – Three Oaks Jay Nogler – Colonel Gray |
| 94-95 | *Mike Sirois – Rural Scott Morrison – Morell Rob Nicol – Three Oaks Scott Bateman – Colonel Gray David Hickey – Rural Jay Nogler – Colonel Gray |
| 95-96 | *Dennis Manning – Colonel Gray Craig Durling – Colonel Gray Mike Saunders – Colonel Gray John Stavert – Bluefield Sean Axworthy – Bluefield Matthew Green – Rural AA |
| 96-97 | *Chris Connolly – Colonel Gray-AA Goran Rudic – Colonel Gray-AA Scott Bateman – Colonel Gray-AA Ryan Schipper – Grace Christian Andrew Whalen – Rural-AA Adam Campbell – Tosh-AA |
| 97-98 | *Andrew Harrison – Three Oaks-AA Andrew Marchbank – Three Oaks-AA Danny Stretch – Bluefield Adam Campbell – Three Oaks-AA Jeff Murphy – Rural-AA Neal Manning – Colonel Gray-AA |
| 98-99 | *Neal Manning – Colonel Gray Brian Finniss – Three Oaks Walter Moyse – Three Oaks Colin Stanley – Colonel Gray Patrick Rossiter – Colonel Gray Jeff Murphy – Rural |
| 99-00 | *Hughie Mullaly – Rural Ryan Paquet – Rural Donnie Killorn – Rural Adam Hood – Hampshire Bluefield Brian Finniss – Three Oaks Chad MacDonald – Colonel Gray |
| 00-01 | *Brian Finniss – Three Oaks Trevor Baille – Three Oaks Ryan Keliher – Charlottetown Rural Doug McKinney – Charlottetown Rural Pat Rossiter – Colonel Gray Ryan Innis – Colonel Gray |
| 01-02 | *Chad MacDonald – Colonel Gray Doug McKinney – Charlottetown Rural Ryan Keliher – Charlottetown Rural Jeff Connolly – Colonel Gray Nic Pharo – Bluefield Morgan Carlile – Three Oaks |
| 02-03 | *Jeff Perry – Charlottetown Gray Morgan Carlile – Three Oaks Taylor Krupa – Hampshire Bluefield Jared MacDonald – Charlottetown Rural Brett Richardson – Charlottetown Gray Jeff Bell – Charlottetown Gray |
| 03-04 | *Brian Hansen – Elmsdale Westisle Steve Simpson – Charlottetown Rural Matt Morrison – Colonel Gray Joel Sauve – Souris Matthew Bolo – Elmsdale Westisle Daniel Gallant – Elmsdale Westisle |
| 04-05 | *Reece Deveaux – Souris Justin MacLean – Three Oaks Brian Hansen – Elmsdale Westisle Marcus Dunphy – Souris Trent Whitty – Charlottetown Rural Steve Walsh – Charlottetown Rural |
| 05-06 | *Jeremy Coffin – Morell Rob Vey – Charlottetown Rural Shawn McKenna – Three Oaks D’Arcy Dubois – Francois Buote Jesse Howatt – Francois Buote Thomas Walsh – Morell |
| 06-07 | *Darcie Handrahan – Elmsdale Westisle Evan Nobles – Montague Kieran Goodwin – Col Gray Jordon McNally – Morell Matt Gough – Elmsdale Westisle Jeremy Coffin – Morell |
| 07-08 | *Logan Sauve – Souris Raymond Walsh – Morell Matt Gough – Elmsdale Westisle Dallas Ellsworth – Elmsdale Westisle Ben McIsaac- Souris Thomas Fisher – Souris |
| 08-09 | *Ray Walsh – Morell-1 Jonathan Gallant – Souris Dexter Coughlin – Three Oaks Will Jadis – Morell-1 Eric Hameline – Montague Damon Ansems – Montague |
| 09-10 | *Dan Hendricken – Morell Dexter Coughlin – Three Oaks-2 Jay Shaw – Montague Will Jadis – Morell Randy Affleck – Morell Chris Buchanan – Westisle |
| 10-11 | *Ylber Gashi – Three Oaks-2 Jay Shaw – Montague Randy Affleck – Morell Stephen MacKinnon – Morell Mackenzie Marchbank – Three Oaks-2 Judah Jacksaw – Three Oaks-2 |
| 11-12 | *Max Xie – Colonel Gray-2 Euan Gorman – Bluefield John McIntosh – Souris Frank Beaton – Colonel Gray-2 Jason Fitzpatrick – Montague Trevor van Weichen – Montague |
| 12-13 | *Kenan Wilkie – Westisle Andrew Rafuse – Three Oaks-2 Aiden Harrington – Kensington Matthew Birt – Souris Matthew MacIntosh – Souris Andrew Gough – Westisle |
| 13-14 | *Nick Frizzell – Charlottetown Rural Josh Stewart – Souris Colton Wadman – Three Oaks Keegan Lazaric – Charlottetown Rural Aiden Harrington – Kensington Jake Reynolds – Kensington |
| 14-15 | *Andrew Gough – Westisle Ethan Craig – Morell Kyle Parlee – Montague Jordan Montgomery – Kensington Mackenzie Corcoran – Kensington Connor Herget – Westisle |
| 15-16 | *Dylan McKinnon – Bluefield Jessie Flemming – Colonel Gray-2 Isaac Cheverie – Bluefield Shane Pendergast – Morell Ethan Craig – Morell Josh McIntosh – Souris |
| 16-17 | Isaac Cheverie – Bluefield-1 Ross Power – Montague Jamaal Scott – Rural-2 Aike Wilting – Bluefield-1 Josh McIntosh – Souris Luke Chaisson – Souris |
| 17-18 | *Elon Wilkie – Westisle-1 Thomas Craig – Morell Tyler MacDonald – Three Oaks-2 Logan Dawson – Westisle-1 Derick Arsenault – Westisle-1 Nolan Ryan- Charlottetown Rural-2 League 1st Donovan Ching – Rural-2 Thomas Craig – Morell Logan Dawson – Westisle-1 Nolan Ryan – Rural-2 Elon Wilkie – Westisle-1 2nd Nathan Eldershaw – Morell Tyler Macdonald – Three Oaks-2 Jonathan Smith – Westisle-1 Rhys Storr – Rural-2 Owen Turner – Three Oaks-2 |
| 18-19 | *Aike Wilting – Bluefield-1 Justin Yang – Rural-2 Hunter Wight – Montague Isaac Compton – Morell Thomas Craig – Morell Nathan Wills – Bluefield-1 League 1st Thomas Craig – Morell Diego McGarry – Morell Tyson Monaghan – Rural-2 Hunter Wight – Montague Aike Wilting – Bluefield-1 Thomas Yeo – Bluefield-1 League 2nd Sawyer Acorn – Montague Isaac Compton – Morell Sam Crockett – Rural Tyler Newson – Bluefield Nic Studzinski – Morell |
| 19-20 | *Matthew Antle – Souris Jack MacKenzie – Montague MacKenzie Plouffe – Bluefield-2 Isaac Chaisson – Souris Steven Acorn – Souris Alex Ryan – Rural-2 LEAGUE 1ST Matthew Antle – Souris Isaac Chaisson – Souris Charles Chang – Colonel Gray-2 Jack MacKenzie – Montague Nic Studzinski – Morell 2nd Steve Acorn – Souris Nick Blanchard – Three Oaks-2 Carson Gray – Rural-2 Hunter Prus – Bluefield-2 Alex Ryan – Rural-2 |
| 20-21 | None selected (cancelled, covid-19 pandemic) |
| 21-22 | *Drake Blacquiere – Three Oaks James Ronahan – Colonel Gray-2 Nathan Wheeler – Rural-2 Parker Murphy – Montague Sawyer Ryan – Montague Cayden Wadman – Three Oaks-3 |
| 22-23 | *Alex Wynne – Rural-2 Nathan Wheeler – Rural-2 Ziad Mohamed – Colonel Gray-2 Brayden Bruce – Colonel Gray-2 Emmett Leclair – Bluefield-2 Finn McCourt – Bluefield-2 Micah Pollard – Montague Jake Jelley – Three Oaks-2 Thomas Gagne – Francois Buote |
| 23-24 | Omaid Ahmadi – Charlottetown Rural-2 Ben Conway – Colonel Gray-2 Ethan Grant – Bluefield-2 Miguel Hernandez – Three Oaks-2 Ethan Lowe – Montague Mason MacNeil – Charlottetown Rural-2 Lance Poitier – Colonel Gray-2 Micah Pollard – Montague Cohen Roberts – Montague Brandon Smith – Three Oaks-2 Justus Tuplin – Westisle-2 |